Is this the questioner that was manhandled from a Brown election meeting in Sunderland? He had asked about fast broadband provision in the north east, and why Brown addressed hand-picked audiences rather than ordinary voters.
Brown refused a response and the voter was dragged outside by a number of people and then given the pointy finger by middle-aged harridan in a red cardigan and a remarkably bad haircut.
Saturday, 1 May 2010
Local Candidates Deserve Some Consideration
This is a revulsion election: revulsion at Mr and Mrs Brown, Mr and Mrs Balls and - still - revulsion at Mr and Mrs Blair. Regardless of party or belief, flying in the face of some widely- and strongly- held convictions, we are going to vote our utter disdain for a small group of self-seeking sycophants. Sycophants of what? Of their self-interest primarily.
And so enormous is the rejection of the values and aims of post-democratic administrative governance by permanent elites, what might be called the caste model of politics, we barely glance at the proposals being put forward by the alternatives. Then, as an aside, we express our dislike for our own lack of acquaintance with the manifestos of others - but it is our own choice to have just familiarity enough to be sure that they still stand for democracy within our own country and throwing the rascals out.
On 6 May we will have more than one vote to cast however. Having scored the ballot paper through to the wood with a cross for the not-Brown-Balls-and the past, candidate we will turn over another paper. Many of the candidates there will be utterly decent people, people bearing Party labels that are badges of honourable local activities and undertakings appropriate to our neighbourhoods and local needs and pleasures. Often we may not have bothered even to turn out to vote for the local elections but this year, as we are determined to be in the polling booths as the nemesis of the big bad Bs, we might pause before the double error of going too far and acting in ignorance. Perhaps we should read the record of the local people, ignore their party labels, and choose without breaking the pencil-lead as we put our crosses.
And so enormous is the rejection of the values and aims of post-democratic administrative governance by permanent elites, what might be called the caste model of politics, we barely glance at the proposals being put forward by the alternatives. Then, as an aside, we express our dislike for our own lack of acquaintance with the manifestos of others - but it is our own choice to have just familiarity enough to be sure that they still stand for democracy within our own country and throwing the rascals out.
On 6 May we will have more than one vote to cast however. Having scored the ballot paper through to the wood with a cross for the not-Brown-Balls-and the past, candidate we will turn over another paper. Many of the candidates there will be utterly decent people, people bearing Party labels that are badges of honourable local activities and undertakings appropriate to our neighbourhoods and local needs and pleasures. Often we may not have bothered even to turn out to vote for the local elections but this year, as we are determined to be in the polling booths as the nemesis of the big bad Bs, we might pause before the double error of going too far and acting in ignorance. Perhaps we should read the record of the local people, ignore their party labels, and choose without breaking the pencil-lead as we put our crosses.
Friday, 30 April 2010
Facing the Music
Birmingham is different from London but the London mindset doesn't realise. Birmingham does England and patriotism. The centuries of industry and manufacturing that conferred such power that Birmingham regarded London as a playground, a divertissement, but no more than an equal in political heft, and readily looked in the eye even on financial resources, have stamped an independence on Birmingham that London has resented and often tried to cripple.
In Birmingham University's Great Hall last night David Cameron's quick ear heard the now so faint but ever-lovely strains of Elgar playing through the gloriously municipal building, heard them still playing in the hearts and minds of the audience seated before the leaders of the parties. Cameron assured us that there would be no euro, that there would be no further invasion of values and culture, that the way out of Brown's economic disaster is work and growth, lowered taxes and encouragement of enterprise, offered the closing down of the client state and a country where people get on with whatever they wish to make of their own lives, while every opportunity to better ourselves is offered within what can be afforded.
Clegg was skewered by his proposals to leave behind the English way of life and embrace some unEnglish - no doubt worthy but not for us - European way. And he knew it; he could hear the Elgar too as he tried to turn down his Party's music (and in Birmingham we know our music, ask Rattle.) But much as Mahler is listened to with interest and respect, Verdi sung with gusto, Faure and Bartok, Schoenberg and Nono puzzled over in Symphony Hall, the Mystery Sonatas venerated in the Oratory - in Birmingham Elgar holds sway.
Brown reminded us all that he had the privilege to have been elected by the people with whom he grew up, where he was at home; in Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath no doubt they have their ways and presumably Gordon Brown embodies them. Those ways do not go down well in Rochdale where plain speaking, honest dealing face to face, with a powerful streak of egalitarianism is also a very English way. Even less do those ways go down in the feisty English Midlands where economic adversity, any adversity, brings out determination, grit, inventiveness, and an intensely romantic strain of pride in country and history - everybody's history, for Birmingham has always had its face turned towards trade and the world. Gordon's globalism, though, doesn't go down in Brum - not the globalism of permanent elites administering global regions and determining resource and wealth allocation, democratically unreachable and with a leading role for Brown. Last night he was forced to face the music.
In Birmingham University's Great Hall last night David Cameron's quick ear heard the now so faint but ever-lovely strains of Elgar playing through the gloriously municipal building, heard them still playing in the hearts and minds of the audience seated before the leaders of the parties. Cameron assured us that there would be no euro, that there would be no further invasion of values and culture, that the way out of Brown's economic disaster is work and growth, lowered taxes and encouragement of enterprise, offered the closing down of the client state and a country where people get on with whatever they wish to make of their own lives, while every opportunity to better ourselves is offered within what can be afforded.
Clegg was skewered by his proposals to leave behind the English way of life and embrace some unEnglish - no doubt worthy but not for us - European way. And he knew it; he could hear the Elgar too as he tried to turn down his Party's music (and in Birmingham we know our music, ask Rattle.) But much as Mahler is listened to with interest and respect, Verdi sung with gusto, Faure and Bartok, Schoenberg and Nono puzzled over in Symphony Hall, the Mystery Sonatas venerated in the Oratory - in Birmingham Elgar holds sway.
Brown reminded us all that he had the privilege to have been elected by the people with whom he grew up, where he was at home; in Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath no doubt they have their ways and presumably Gordon Brown embodies them. Those ways do not go down well in Rochdale where plain speaking, honest dealing face to face, with a powerful streak of egalitarianism is also a very English way. Even less do those ways go down in the feisty English Midlands where economic adversity, any adversity, brings out determination, grit, inventiveness, and an intensely romantic strain of pride in country and history - everybody's history, for Birmingham has always had its face turned towards trade and the world. Gordon's globalism, though, doesn't go down in Brum - not the globalism of permanent elites administering global regions and determining resource and wealth allocation, democratically unreachable and with a leading role for Brown. Last night he was forced to face the music.
Thursday, 29 April 2010
Brown Should Speak in the Debate Tonight to Mrs Duffy and Other Humans
Many would vote for what Mrs Duffy would vote for. Now, like Mrs Duffy, they won't be voting for a Labour party led by Gordon Brown.
Protect the vulnerable, treat others as you want to be treated yourself, be fair, work hard:
"It was drummed into us as children," said the mortified, courteous, so obviously kind and decent woman.
Each of us has been shocked by a different aspect of how disgraceful Brown is. The specious response to millions of impoverished people from the former countries of realised socialism migrating into an advanced capitalist country to possess the social wage capitalism can provide grated particularly for me:
"There are over a million people from Britain living in Europe".
These are not people demanding social housing, educational provision, cash welfare benefits, and all the health services that go with the formation of young families - services and tax-funded provision to which the refugees from socialist reality have made no contribution. The people from England living in continental Europe buy their own houses, bring or earn their own incomes and tend to return home for any serious claim they may be unfortunate enough to need to make on health care. They make no claims for cash welfare payments, not least because these are not available to them.
Liars lie in many forms and Brown rivals Lucifer in claims to be Prince of Lies. If, this evening, we are fed mouthfuls of balderdash about global vision, saving the world, and institutionalising global governance and regulation, what will echo through my mind will be the misrepresentations to Mrs Duffy on the equivalence of immigrants and emigrants in our country. That and the abused and shaken Mrs Duffy internalising the destruction of a lifetime's, a family's , committment to decency and politics practised on a human scale by normal human beings.
Protect the vulnerable, treat others as you want to be treated yourself, be fair, work hard:
"It was drummed into us as children," said the mortified, courteous, so obviously kind and decent woman.
Each of us has been shocked by a different aspect of how disgraceful Brown is. The specious response to millions of impoverished people from the former countries of realised socialism migrating into an advanced capitalist country to possess the social wage capitalism can provide grated particularly for me:
"There are over a million people from Britain living in Europe".
These are not people demanding social housing, educational provision, cash welfare benefits, and all the health services that go with the formation of young families - services and tax-funded provision to which the refugees from socialist reality have made no contribution. The people from England living in continental Europe buy their own houses, bring or earn their own incomes and tend to return home for any serious claim they may be unfortunate enough to need to make on health care. They make no claims for cash welfare payments, not least because these are not available to them.
Liars lie in many forms and Brown rivals Lucifer in claims to be Prince of Lies. If, this evening, we are fed mouthfuls of balderdash about global vision, saving the world, and institutionalising global governance and regulation, what will echo through my mind will be the misrepresentations to Mrs Duffy on the equivalence of immigrants and emigrants in our country. That and the abused and shaken Mrs Duffy internalising the destruction of a lifetime's, a family's , committment to decency and politics practised on a human scale by normal human beings.
Wednesday, 28 April 2010
That'll be Brown and his Behaviour
Bigot / n. [Fr., of unknown origin.] 1. A hypocrtical or superstitious adherent of religion. 2. An obstinate and unreasonable adherent of a religious or other opinion; an intolerant and narrow-minded person.
Bigotry / n. Obstinate and unreasonable adherence to an opinion.....narrow-minded intolerance.
Bigotry / n. Obstinate and unreasonable adherence to an opinion.....narrow-minded intolerance.
Tuesday, 27 April 2010
Respecting Belief
Catholics must be considering their usual allegiance to Labour. Taught from their Catechism that the man who is Pope is as vulnerable to falling into sin as any other Christian but that in the exercise of his office as Peter's successor and Vicar of Christ he is guided by the Holy Ghost and, on occasion, infallible, the popiness of him demands respect. And a state visit to this country is a papal, if temporal, act. With spiritual aspects.
If the insults offered to the spiritual duties laid upon roman Catholics had come from an ostensibly political source they would have been less offensive; many find the politics of others offensive and it is recognised that politicians are, therefore, likely to attract opprobrium. But these insults to the spiritual duties Catholics embrace came from those who Catholics, along with others, pay to carry out state organisational tasks. From a permanent establishment apparently infected and the infection condoned.
To publish a political and cultural assault upon the Catholic tenets of chastity, marriage, the sanctity of life at conception, the creation of humanity in God's image, as well as the implied criticism of indulgence in the sin of an over-luxurious personal life-style, makes plain that the spiritual weight of the papal visit is recognised. This not just a temporal head of state visiting another, and England is not just any country in its spiritual status. Hence, presumably, the sheer venemous vulgarity of the mode of attack.
None of the civil servants involved should have remained in post. They have betrayed more than inappropriate attitudes to their work, they have spat hatred at millions of their fellow citizens, and attempted to assert cultural beliefs and values which, in fairness, have become associated with Labour only relatively recently, in the last half century. Clearly the attitudes betrayed in the documents circulated - bound to emerge despite futile attempts to limit their publication and now known to us all - are widespread enough in government departments to require more senior staff to be removed as well.
The Church is right to feel profoundly disturbed by this manifestation and will be even more concerned at what kinds of dangers now threaten the faithful in a country where the ruling political party embodies such attitudes and encourages their embedding into what is supposed to be apolitical administration. The advice it offers to the faithful must be under urgent reconsideration.
If the insults offered to the spiritual duties laid upon roman Catholics had come from an ostensibly political source they would have been less offensive; many find the politics of others offensive and it is recognised that politicians are, therefore, likely to attract opprobrium. But these insults to the spiritual duties Catholics embrace came from those who Catholics, along with others, pay to carry out state organisational tasks. From a permanent establishment apparently infected and the infection condoned.
To publish a political and cultural assault upon the Catholic tenets of chastity, marriage, the sanctity of life at conception, the creation of humanity in God's image, as well as the implied criticism of indulgence in the sin of an over-luxurious personal life-style, makes plain that the spiritual weight of the papal visit is recognised. This not just a temporal head of state visiting another, and England is not just any country in its spiritual status. Hence, presumably, the sheer venemous vulgarity of the mode of attack.
None of the civil servants involved should have remained in post. They have betrayed more than inappropriate attitudes to their work, they have spat hatred at millions of their fellow citizens, and attempted to assert cultural beliefs and values which, in fairness, have become associated with Labour only relatively recently, in the last half century. Clearly the attitudes betrayed in the documents circulated - bound to emerge despite futile attempts to limit their publication and now known to us all - are widespread enough in government departments to require more senior staff to be removed as well.
The Church is right to feel profoundly disturbed by this manifestation and will be even more concerned at what kinds of dangers now threaten the faithful in a country where the ruling political party embodies such attitudes and encourages their embedding into what is supposed to be apolitical administration. The advice it offers to the faithful must be under urgent reconsideration.
Sunday, 25 April 2010
It's Not the Economy
The nation state is at the heart of this election campaign. Not the wrecked economy but the boundaries of the economy that has been wrecked since 1997. If an ideology of trans-national boundaries in economic administration or, for socialists, planning, is the bedrock of economic understanding, then measures of failure distort and even disappear. And in doing so the charges of incompetence, malevolence, unmandated political direction and the implementation of elitist agendas embedded in immovable supra-national institutions fall. If the nation state is defined as the root of all evil we attack too the democratic individualism that overthrew emperors and monarchs, popes and tyrants, tsars and eastern potentates.
When we identify ourseves with England or Scotland we identify our political society with our democracy which defends our commonality of interest and sets the standards of policy and behaviour for our elected representatives. We choose people of our kind to look after our interests and maintain decent relations with similarly organised but different peoples. Our democratic nation states may have parties within them standing for alternative understandings and actions to make a good society but we should be able to be sure that these parties are standing on the same ground, of nation and of state.
The dismissal of Italy as merely a geographical expression roused such ferocious expressions of nationalism and cultural identity as to bring down at least two European empires. New Labour's attempts to dismiss England (and the other countries of the United Kingdom) as merely a geographical expression, a north western European province whose administration falls in with parts of France and parts of Scandinavia, denies cultural and political coherence even to the misty romanticism of the British Isles.
'Let us assume' begin so many economic arguments and analyses. The economic argument with which Labour intend to pursue us in the last phase of the electoral campaign assumes priority to the building of global governance, the regulation of the globalised economy, to the irrelevance of the confines within which the last thirteen years of financial and economic policy can be defined as abject failure.
In truth, placing our economy at the centre of attention places betrayal at the centre of discussion and consideration, for it places our democracy and our nation state there too.
When we identify ourseves with England or Scotland we identify our political society with our democracy which defends our commonality of interest and sets the standards of policy and behaviour for our elected representatives. We choose people of our kind to look after our interests and maintain decent relations with similarly organised but different peoples. Our democratic nation states may have parties within them standing for alternative understandings and actions to make a good society but we should be able to be sure that these parties are standing on the same ground, of nation and of state.
The dismissal of Italy as merely a geographical expression roused such ferocious expressions of nationalism and cultural identity as to bring down at least two European empires. New Labour's attempts to dismiss England (and the other countries of the United Kingdom) as merely a geographical expression, a north western European province whose administration falls in with parts of France and parts of Scandinavia, denies cultural and political coherence even to the misty romanticism of the British Isles.
'Let us assume' begin so many economic arguments and analyses. The economic argument with which Labour intend to pursue us in the last phase of the electoral campaign assumes priority to the building of global governance, the regulation of the globalised economy, to the irrelevance of the confines within which the last thirteen years of financial and economic policy can be defined as abject failure.
In truth, placing our economy at the centre of attention places betrayal at the centre of discussion and consideration, for it places our democracy and our nation state there too.
Saturday, 24 April 2010
The UK Economy is Just a Little Local Difficulty in the Wider Scheme of Things
The illiterate gobbledygook in which the latest G20 communique is issued (what does progressive governance have against verbs?) is about to be inflicted upon the country from close quarters as the Prime Minister moves, from meet-and-tell cosyings-up with young admirers in provincial playing fields and off the settees of northern Labour pensioners now retired from their years of unemployment, to seize the centre stage of the election campaign. Gordon has shed Sarah the Carer and escaped from his mandelsonian out of sight out of mind purdah.
We, the country, as the Communique might put it, are going to be told how runs the global economy under Saviour of the World leadership. And because of its very globalism, unfortunate standard of living and life chances outcomes in our United Kingdom economy will be set into the perspective of being a mere and temporary regional blip that will be set right as soon as others fully grasp the interdependencies of the global economy.
As soon, that is, as those who have not incurred consumption debt and have lived within their means, earning their country's living by manufacturing, industrial production, innovation and various services provision within a modern mixed economy, have ended their selfish refusal to incur debt for consumption of what we produce - such as unregulated, verging into criminal, financial services, and gun running, and recognised our contribution to global balanced growth - how much they owe to our borrowing and consumption.
What they must learn is where would they be without us? What we must learn is that it is right to play our part in helping emerging economies onto the sunlit uplands of higher living standards by exchanging freshly printed notes (not the scruffy, been through far too many hands too fast sort) for their goods and natural resources. And we will provide the institutions, the regulation that will ensure the smooth working of the whole. Why, we could be thought of as the Greeks to their..... Mmm, perhaps not Greeks.
We, the country, as the Communique might put it, are going to be told how runs the global economy under Saviour of the World leadership. And because of its very globalism, unfortunate standard of living and life chances outcomes in our United Kingdom economy will be set into the perspective of being a mere and temporary regional blip that will be set right as soon as others fully grasp the interdependencies of the global economy.
As soon, that is, as those who have not incurred consumption debt and have lived within their means, earning their country's living by manufacturing, industrial production, innovation and various services provision within a modern mixed economy, have ended their selfish refusal to incur debt for consumption of what we produce - such as unregulated, verging into criminal, financial services, and gun running, and recognised our contribution to global balanced growth - how much they owe to our borrowing and consumption.
What they must learn is where would they be without us? What we must learn is that it is right to play our part in helping emerging economies onto the sunlit uplands of higher living standards by exchanging freshly printed notes (not the scruffy, been through far too many hands too fast sort) for their goods and natural resources. And we will provide the institutions, the regulation that will ensure the smooth working of the whole. Why, we could be thought of as the Greeks to their..... Mmm, perhaps not Greeks.
Friday, 23 April 2010
Persisting in Economic Error
It isn't about the fantasy of 'protecting the fragile recovery'. It isn't about raising taxes, or pretending that not raising taxes is the same thing as 'taking billions out of the economy'. It isn't about 'saving jobs'. All of this is a disturbed attempt to frame an economic disaster as if it hasn't happened yet.
It has happened, as today's figures on the economy and recent returns on unemployment show. Taxes have been raised to levels that have dropped consumption like a stone once consumption cannot be financed by inappropriately extended credit; credit that has indebted the least economically defended, the least able to bear debt, placed them in a dark and threatening landscape where their living standards are compromised for decades and their basic life needs - housing, energy, food, water, transport, are hanging not by a thread perhaps, but by a very thin cord.
Employment? Many - millions - survive without waged employment and their numbers rise steadily, breaking sad record after sad record. Saddest of all worklessness stretches deeper and further into communities excluded from earning their living not just from lack of skills, inadequate re-skilling opportunities, inappropriately focused investment both private but principally public, and the exposure to the export of work - so much more damaging than the import of cheap labour - but extends now to those who are able and capable but undermined by government interference levels in the economy that render it susceptible to the analyses once used to understand why planned economies failed. Just as in those economies we have now unmet demand from lack of capacity, gross underemployment masquerading as work in the public sector, high levels of unemployed younger workers in 'training' that leads to no work, crowding out of private sector investment by government expenditure, deliberate obstruction by bureaucratic regulation of private enterprise, and ever lower growth accompanied by ever meaner living standards; the whole garnished with repressed inflation.
Our economy is in the worst shape of any economy in the West and, to Labour's utter shame, in the East freed from realised socialism as well. There is a lot of fat, certainly, but no longer for growing numbers who see their savings giving no return, their pensions slashed, their family members without hope of waged work. And that 'fat' is attracting supra-national asset strippers from whom government seems unwilling to protect us, as they obsess on the attractions of globalisation and their role as an elite of global governance.
The whole game plan of Gordon Brown is in error. That he was enabled by Labour's lack of democracy and by a culture of political bullying and thuggery to ruin so much and so many is frightening; but to accept any misrepresentation of what has created our current condition as a basis for persisting would be utter foolishness. The reason he has never apologised for what he has done is that he still thinks he is right. That alone disqualifies him from any further political career.
It has happened, as today's figures on the economy and recent returns on unemployment show. Taxes have been raised to levels that have dropped consumption like a stone once consumption cannot be financed by inappropriately extended credit; credit that has indebted the least economically defended, the least able to bear debt, placed them in a dark and threatening landscape where their living standards are compromised for decades and their basic life needs - housing, energy, food, water, transport, are hanging not by a thread perhaps, but by a very thin cord.
Employment? Many - millions - survive without waged employment and their numbers rise steadily, breaking sad record after sad record. Saddest of all worklessness stretches deeper and further into communities excluded from earning their living not just from lack of skills, inadequate re-skilling opportunities, inappropriately focused investment both private but principally public, and the exposure to the export of work - so much more damaging than the import of cheap labour - but extends now to those who are able and capable but undermined by government interference levels in the economy that render it susceptible to the analyses once used to understand why planned economies failed. Just as in those economies we have now unmet demand from lack of capacity, gross underemployment masquerading as work in the public sector, high levels of unemployed younger workers in 'training' that leads to no work, crowding out of private sector investment by government expenditure, deliberate obstruction by bureaucratic regulation of private enterprise, and ever lower growth accompanied by ever meaner living standards; the whole garnished with repressed inflation.
Our economy is in the worst shape of any economy in the West and, to Labour's utter shame, in the East freed from realised socialism as well. There is a lot of fat, certainly, but no longer for growing numbers who see their savings giving no return, their pensions slashed, their family members without hope of waged work. And that 'fat' is attracting supra-national asset strippers from whom government seems unwilling to protect us, as they obsess on the attractions of globalisation and their role as an elite of global governance.
The whole game plan of Gordon Brown is in error. That he was enabled by Labour's lack of democracy and by a culture of political bullying and thuggery to ruin so much and so many is frightening; but to accept any misrepresentation of what has created our current condition as a basis for persisting would be utter foolishness. The reason he has never apologised for what he has done is that he still thinks he is right. That alone disqualifies him from any further political career.
Wednesday, 21 April 2010
Capacity Constraints: Skills, Machines, Finance
'Sir, The public discussion about cutting the budget deficit is virtually confined to cutting government expenditure or raising taxes. But it doesn’t have to be like this. The national accounts, with a little manipulation, tell us that the deficit is always exactly equal to private disposable income less private expenditure less the balance of payments.
This is to say that any reduction in the government deficit can in principle be brought about either by an increase in private expenditure relative to disposable income or an increase in exports relative to imports. The expansionary route will reduce the deficit leaving output higher than it would be if the disinflationary path were followed.
My main purpose in writing this down is to enlarge the sphere for discourse and I do not pretend that the expansionary route would be easy to put into effect. Exports could be raised relative to imports especially if the pound were further devalued; the increase in exports was certainly substantial in the early 1970s and 1990s. It is possible that private investment would surge in a more expansionary atmosphere.
Wynne Godley,
King's College, Cambridge. ' [letter to the Financial Times 20 April.]
Wrong, wrong, wrong.
Boosting consumption has been tried with credit expansion to the credit unworthy and the bubble has burst.
Export promotion and import substitution should have occurred by now as a result of sterling devaluation by over a third in the last two years, unfortunately capacity constraints invalidate the argument. Skills, plant, finance, demand.
Fiscal austerity is the only way out in these circumstances, where the problem is not just effective demand but the structural de-skilling of the labour force.
We are in the long run, and the skilled workers are all dead.
This is to say that any reduction in the government deficit can in principle be brought about either by an increase in private expenditure relative to disposable income or an increase in exports relative to imports. The expansionary route will reduce the deficit leaving output higher than it would be if the disinflationary path were followed.
My main purpose in writing this down is to enlarge the sphere for discourse and I do not pretend that the expansionary route would be easy to put into effect. Exports could be raised relative to imports especially if the pound were further devalued; the increase in exports was certainly substantial in the early 1970s and 1990s. It is possible that private investment would surge in a more expansionary atmosphere.
Wynne Godley,
King's College, Cambridge. ' [letter to the Financial Times 20 April.]
Wrong, wrong, wrong.
Boosting consumption has been tried with credit expansion to the credit unworthy and the bubble has burst.
Export promotion and import substitution should have occurred by now as a result of sterling devaluation by over a third in the last two years, unfortunately capacity constraints invalidate the argument. Skills, plant, finance, demand.
Fiscal austerity is the only way out in these circumstances, where the problem is not just effective demand but the structural de-skilling of the labour force.
We are in the long run, and the skilled workers are all dead.
The Monster From Fife
A six-legged scorpion about two metres long and one metre wide, leaving tracks of which a cast is being made, has been found in Fife. The tracks were left as it crawled over sand. Scottish Natural Heritage described the find as unique and internationally important because the creature is gigantic.
It is to be be moulded in silicone so that more people can see and research it. Richard Batchelor from Geoheritage Fife, said:
"Removing it and housing it in a museum would be prohibitively costly but moulding it in silicone rubber and making copies for educational and research purposes means that we can still see and research this huge creature's tracks in years to come."
This artist's impression, released today, is of the creature under medication.
Tuesday, 20 April 2010
Worn Out Armaments, Outworn Rhetoric
United Kingdom Armed Forces are very badly equipped. They are badly equipped to fight low tech war in a seriously under-developed country; heaven knows what their condition would be in taking on a seriously equipped foe. In Iraq our Forces were effectively confined to the Basra airbase for years. All the lying Brown years of returning troops, and all the betrayal Brown years when he refused to fund their role in Iraq's south and they died in their inadequate vehicles and under their lack of air cover and without communications equipment from this century.
Brown should never have brought the Ark Royal to our attention. Cutting steel now for the UK's aircraft carriers is a Brownian period too late. Just look at other European aircraft carriers, currently at sea, not launched in the mind's eye of liars providing jobs for own-voters rather than effective defence for our country. And even if the UK's new aircraft carriers are ever finished, there are no planes budgeted for, never mind being built in the UK, once a distinguished supplier of aircraft innovation, design, engineering and supply.
From New Labour - vainglorious warmongering on the cheap, except for the lives of the troops. From other countries - hard-headed assessment of what they need for their interests and defence with troops trained, equipped, and supported by their governments, from body armour to conflict negotiation and resolution, from boots to helicopters, and aircraft carriers and aircraft of the 21st century.
Brown should never have brought the Ark Royal to our attention. Cutting steel now for the UK's aircraft carriers is a Brownian period too late. Just look at other European aircraft carriers, currently at sea, not launched in the mind's eye of liars providing jobs for own-voters rather than effective defence for our country. And even if the UK's new aircraft carriers are ever finished, there are no planes budgeted for, never mind being built in the UK, once a distinguished supplier of aircraft innovation, design, engineering and supply.
From New Labour - vainglorious warmongering on the cheap, except for the lives of the troops. From other countries - hard-headed assessment of what they need for their interests and defence with troops trained, equipped, and supported by their governments, from body armour to conflict negotiation and resolution, from boots to helicopters, and aircraft carriers and aircraft of the 21st century.
Monday, 19 April 2010
Compare and Contrast
The aircraft carrier Cavour, equipped with all its helicopters, field hospitals, skilled personnel etc., was despatched to Haiti to help after the worst earthquake for over a century. It was un atto dovuto, an act required of our country in common humanity said the Head of State.
The aircraft carrier Ark Royal has been deployed as a Channel ferry to 'bring home' 'stranded Britons' who have failed to ensure that they can cope should pre-paid cheap travel tickets not be usable on set dates.
The Brown regime sent some corrugated iron sheets to Haiti, and sends the Ark Royal to Calais.
UPDATE (just to add uselesness to the wrongness of using the Royal Navy's flagship as a ferry boat)
From the Times:
'...two of the three Royal Navy warships dispatched this morning to rescue stranded travellers still do not have an assigned destination.
Eight hours after Gordon Brown’s announcement, a Ministry of Defence spokesperson said that neither HMS Ark Royal nor HMS Ocean had been given a destination and that it was “unlikely” that any British passengers would be picked up tonight.
A spokesperson for P&O Ferries said that the plans to bring in the Navy were little more than a gesture. “It might sound attractive to get in an aircraft carrier to take 1,000 people at a time, but we can carry five times that capacity. If anything is needed, it’s a large, purpose-built foot passenger ferry to scoop them all up.
“The lion’s share of the repatriation will be done by professional ferry companies working all along the French coast...'
The aircraft carrier Ark Royal has been deployed as a Channel ferry to 'bring home' 'stranded Britons' who have failed to ensure that they can cope should pre-paid cheap travel tickets not be usable on set dates.
The Brown regime sent some corrugated iron sheets to Haiti, and sends the Ark Royal to Calais.
UPDATE (just to add uselesness to the wrongness of using the Royal Navy's flagship as a ferry boat)
From the Times:
'...two of the three Royal Navy warships dispatched this morning to rescue stranded travellers still do not have an assigned destination.
Eight hours after Gordon Brown’s announcement, a Ministry of Defence spokesperson said that neither HMS Ark Royal nor HMS Ocean had been given a destination and that it was “unlikely” that any British passengers would be picked up tonight.
A spokesperson for P&O Ferries said that the plans to bring in the Navy were little more than a gesture. “It might sound attractive to get in an aircraft carrier to take 1,000 people at a time, but we can carry five times that capacity. If anything is needed, it’s a large, purpose-built foot passenger ferry to scoop them all up.
“The lion’s share of the repatriation will be done by professional ferry companies working all along the French coast...'
Just Able to Afford a Package Holiday is not Enough
The fragility of the arrangements some people, often with children, have made when travelling to countries of which they know nothing continues to surprise. On the evening news we watch English families in objectively quite scary situations who have simply thrown themselves on the mercies of Italians. The Italians are being efficient and generous, camp beds in the airports, food and drink being handed out, blankets provided, the use of public buildings permitted and patrolled by the civil protection volunteers; but who are these people who have left home without the means to support themselves and their families if their travel arrangements are disturbed for more than a few hours? What sense of irresponsible adventure or entitlement has led them to act as if they are student backpackers without limit of time and without needs beyond bare necessities?
One man declared that he had paid for a week's all-in holiday including fares, and thought it was for someone else to ensure they arrived back in Britain safely. He's in the middle of Rome, shortly to be in the middle of the night, peeved to discover that Rome hotels are booked full all year round and he cannot stay beyond his booking, without money, unable to speak Italian, and with young children displaying the vacant-eyed exhaustion of the literally stressed-out. A small HG, acting as translator, accompanied a friend to Santa Maria Novella station which was under assault for trains to all parts of Italy and to the rest of Europe; including a desperate mob of English people, with small children, unable to grasp that even if they got to Paris (which would not be till next Friday) they live on an island and there is no way across the Channel till even later. Hotel rooms in Florence don't grow on trees in April either, they were going to have to spread out into a fifty-kilometre circle round the city - but most simply didn't have the money to buy their way out of their days'-long bivouac.
Travelling hundreds, thousands of kilometres from home - home that supplies a large part of the standard of living in non-monetary form - is foolish; partly it is the result of not understanding that they are only not-very-poor-indeed in a very small home territory. All these people are still there this morning, in 24 hours' worse shape, and trying the patience and good samaritan qualities of their increasingly unhappy hosts, who would prefer their public spaces and services to be called on for true, not self-inflicted emergencies.
Perhaps it is time to require tourists to demonstrate their immediate access to sufficient funds to finance themselves independently for the length again of their stay abroad; that would cover most return delays, limit the dangers to which indigent travellers are currently exposed, return the civil protection and police services to their proper tasks, and clear the streets, stations, and airports.
One man declared that he had paid for a week's all-in holiday including fares, and thought it was for someone else to ensure they arrived back in Britain safely. He's in the middle of Rome, shortly to be in the middle of the night, peeved to discover that Rome hotels are booked full all year round and he cannot stay beyond his booking, without money, unable to speak Italian, and with young children displaying the vacant-eyed exhaustion of the literally stressed-out. A small HG, acting as translator, accompanied a friend to Santa Maria Novella station which was under assault for trains to all parts of Italy and to the rest of Europe; including a desperate mob of English people, with small children, unable to grasp that even if they got to Paris (which would not be till next Friday) they live on an island and there is no way across the Channel till even later. Hotel rooms in Florence don't grow on trees in April either, they were going to have to spread out into a fifty-kilometre circle round the city - but most simply didn't have the money to buy their way out of their days'-long bivouac.
Travelling hundreds, thousands of kilometres from home - home that supplies a large part of the standard of living in non-monetary form - is foolish; partly it is the result of not understanding that they are only not-very-poor-indeed in a very small home territory. All these people are still there this morning, in 24 hours' worse shape, and trying the patience and good samaritan qualities of their increasingly unhappy hosts, who would prefer their public spaces and services to be called on for true, not self-inflicted emergencies.
Perhaps it is time to require tourists to demonstrate their immediate access to sufficient funds to finance themselves independently for the length again of their stay abroad; that would cover most return delays, limit the dangers to which indigent travellers are currently exposed, return the civil protection and police services to their proper tasks, and clear the streets, stations, and airports.
Sunday, 18 April 2010
Defending Democracy Means defending the Nation State
A 'vision of creating a global institution to help reconstruct countries where civil society was broken; a global environmental organisation to tackle climate change; and a global financial system which serves the people.' is a vision of dystopia, of undemocratic progressive, unreachable elites administering the lives out of us.
Speaking to academics, international development campaigners and supporters in Milton Keynes, the Saviour of the world and Leader of the Labour party went on to declare that he wanted to provide more [enough already, ed.] support to international development agencies.
No-one could call Tony Judt right wing. This most distinguished of historians whose clear-eyed and magnificent grasp of the history of our times is always from the viewpoint of a humanitarian, enlightened, individualism informed by a grasp of collectivist philosophies and what can be achieved by state action. Here he speaks of attempts to end democracy and the nation state:
The state here discussed is, of course, the nation state, not the nanny state which, in truth, is merely temporary government. It is this 'state we have known since the 18th century', that globalists and their mad prophets use temporarily stolen power to undermine.
Now we can vote brownism out, deprive him of our nation state, push back the delusions of an unhinged usurper of our democratic mandate. Certainly there are global forces but there is no global governance under democratic control. What there is, the corrupt and grossly out-dated vehicles of post 1945 power settlements - the UN, the G whatever numbers, the EU, posing as the apolitical, evolutionarily and morally superior successors to the means and defence of our democratic politic and our individual freedom, should be rejected by all our citizens.
[Tony Judt. Ill Fares the Land: a Treatise on Our Present Discontents. Allen Lane, 2010. ]
Speaking to academics, international development campaigners and supporters in Milton Keynes, the Saviour of the world and Leader of the Labour party went on to declare that he wanted to provide more [enough already, ed.] support to international development agencies.
"What people say is impossible and beyond our reach can happen,". [not if we can help it, ed.]
'Mr Brown used images of World War II, the Holocaust, Apartheid in South Africa, Ethiopia, Rwanda, the Balkans and the Congo to illustrate what he said was a continuing progression of worldwide values towards a more compassionate and 'global society'. (Telegraph). [if you're not scared now there's no scaring you, ed.]
No-one could call Tony Judt right wing. This most distinguished of historians whose clear-eyed and magnificent grasp of the history of our times is always from the viewpoint of a humanitarian, enlightened, individualism informed by a grasp of collectivist philosophies and what can be achieved by state action. Here he speaks of attempts to end democracy and the nation state:
'We have no good reason to suppose that economic globalization translates smoothly into political freedom. ...China (like many other Asian economies) is not just a low wage country - it is also and above all a 'low rights' country. And it is the absence of rights which keeps wages down ...meanwhile depressing the rights of workers with which China competes...'
'When banks fail, when large scale corrective action is called for... there is just the state as we have known it since the 18th century. That is all we have. ...'
'Populations experiencing increased economic and physical insecurity will retreat to the political symbols, legal resources, and physical barriers that only a territorial state can provide. ... wages, hours, pensions and everything that matters to the working population of a country are still negotiated - and contested - locally. With the strains born of globalization and its attendant crises, the state will be called upon with mounting insistence to resolve the tensions that result. As the only institution standing between individuals and non-state actors like banks or international corporations: as the sole regulatory unit occupying the space between transnational agencies and local interests....'
'..just as the intermediate institutions of society - political parties, trade unions, constitutions and laws - impeded the powers of kings and tyrants, so the state itself may now be the primary 'intermediate institution': standing between powerless, insecure citizens and the unresponsive, unaccountable corporations or international agencies. And the state - or at least the democratic state - retains a unique legitimacy in the eyes of its citizens. It alone answers to them, and they to it.'
The state here discussed is, of course, the nation state, not the nanny state which, in truth, is merely temporary government. It is this 'state we have known since the 18th century', that globalists and their mad prophets use temporarily stolen power to undermine.
Now we can vote brownism out, deprive him of our nation state, push back the delusions of an unhinged usurper of our democratic mandate. Certainly there are global forces but there is no global governance under democratic control. What there is, the corrupt and grossly out-dated vehicles of post 1945 power settlements - the UN, the G whatever numbers, the EU, posing as the apolitical, evolutionarily and morally superior successors to the means and defence of our democratic politic and our individual freedom, should be rejected by all our citizens.
[Tony Judt. Ill Fares the Land: a Treatise on Our Present Discontents. Allen Lane, 2010. ]
Saturday, 17 April 2010
There Is A Green Hill Far Away
Overheard on leaving the cinema in central London:
"If Gordon Brown gets in I'm going to buy myself a hill in Umbria."
Umbria is not Tuscany, but there are no hills for sale there either. Not any more. Should have done it thirteen years ago.
"If Gordon Brown gets in I'm going to buy myself a hill in Umbria."
Umbria is not Tuscany, but there are no hills for sale there either. Not any more. Should have done it thirteen years ago.
Brown Cannot Serve Us Now Any More Than He Ever Could
Silvio Berlusconi offered Italian citizens low taxes, action on immigration, drastic reductions in bureaucratic interference in people's lives. Angela Merkel offered low taxes, action on immigration, no Turkish membership of the EU, a cut in bureaucratic interference in people's lives, and stability - stability expressed as protection from international and global economic forces. Many dislike both of them, but most have settled for the broad policy bases that are all democracy can deliver.
Brown's Labour offers high and ever higher taxes, high levels of immigration, grotesque rises in bureaucratic interference in people's lives, a country so unstable that its borrowing costs are the third highest (after Greece and Portugal) in Europe; and globalisation.
Labour hasn't the slightest chance of winning the election; what it is manouevring for is some kind of coalition with Brown retaining the prime ministership. The United Kingdom is an electoral dictatorship (except in the case of Brown where the courtesy of an electoral mandate has been dispensed with until forced upon him, and he has governed using his predecessor's mandate) which is renewed or with held every four or five years or so. Who is prime minister is king, in some ways quite literally holding the powers of the monarch; and all the cabinet government stuff belongs in political science text books of the 1950s (and earlier).
Why should Brown be given a dictator's mandate? The moment the centre-left of the electorate saw that a vote for the Liberal Democrats would not be a vote wasted they were off and running from their sad subservience to the Brown faction who hold in thrall what has been, for so long, the main party of the centre left.
What is more, there is the consistent expression of a desire for 'a hung parliament', ie., for a grand coalition government of all the centre parties that will deliver low taxes, action on immigration, a cut in bureaucratic interference in people's lives, and stability, with protection from international and global economic forces (of which immigration is but part).
Brown can deliver none of this. He is its antithesis: his is narrow, sectional rule, exclusive even of most of the Labour party - never mind the electorate. He stands on a programme rejected decisively in Italy and Germany (I choose these comparison electorates as Italy is a country with a similar standard of living, size of population and with an only slightly larger economy; while Germany is the kind of economy we might hope to have with sensible and similar policies.) And in Italy and Germany the Social Democrats languish in the low 20s of electoral support while they come to terms with smaller state and lower taxes policies.
The United Kingdom does not have a social democrat default setting. It is centre-right in its political culture - indeed it has to be restrained in its more atavistic right-wingness by its own centre-right leaders. For a grand coalition to be constructed there are going to have to be compromises, mostly on our relationship with Europe; but there are solutions to finding agreement through our Parliament and constitution that are ours to use and the electorate's to settle, without any permission-seeking from Brussels, just as is done in Italy and Germany. Also the mitbestimmung contribution to Germany's economic success must find its English transformation and place in our 're-balancing' of our economy. The federation of the four countries that make up the United Kingdom needs 're-balancing' too, with parliaments for each and federal relationships more respectful of the interests and cultures of our constituent parts.
There is no place for Brown in any of this; he has betrayed our sane interest for his entire political life, let alone his thirteen years in office. Those to the right of centre can vote for the Conservatives, those who are social democrats will divide between Liberals and Labour, but all of us must be aware that Brown has no interest in bowing to electoral withholding of his mandate, nor capacity to build what we all want, and need, to emerge from the disaster he has made.
Our first objective must be to vote Brown from office, any office, for he can make no contribution to political life nor can anything he stands for.
Brown's Labour offers high and ever higher taxes, high levels of immigration, grotesque rises in bureaucratic interference in people's lives, a country so unstable that its borrowing costs are the third highest (after Greece and Portugal) in Europe; and globalisation.
Labour hasn't the slightest chance of winning the election; what it is manouevring for is some kind of coalition with Brown retaining the prime ministership. The United Kingdom is an electoral dictatorship (except in the case of Brown where the courtesy of an electoral mandate has been dispensed with until forced upon him, and he has governed using his predecessor's mandate) which is renewed or with held every four or five years or so. Who is prime minister is king, in some ways quite literally holding the powers of the monarch; and all the cabinet government stuff belongs in political science text books of the 1950s (and earlier).
Why should Brown be given a dictator's mandate? The moment the centre-left of the electorate saw that a vote for the Liberal Democrats would not be a vote wasted they were off and running from their sad subservience to the Brown faction who hold in thrall what has been, for so long, the main party of the centre left.
What is more, there is the consistent expression of a desire for 'a hung parliament', ie., for a grand coalition government of all the centre parties that will deliver low taxes, action on immigration, a cut in bureaucratic interference in people's lives, and stability, with protection from international and global economic forces (of which immigration is but part).
Brown can deliver none of this. He is its antithesis: his is narrow, sectional rule, exclusive even of most of the Labour party - never mind the electorate. He stands on a programme rejected decisively in Italy and Germany (I choose these comparison electorates as Italy is a country with a similar standard of living, size of population and with an only slightly larger economy; while Germany is the kind of economy we might hope to have with sensible and similar policies.) And in Italy and Germany the Social Democrats languish in the low 20s of electoral support while they come to terms with smaller state and lower taxes policies.
The United Kingdom does not have a social democrat default setting. It is centre-right in its political culture - indeed it has to be restrained in its more atavistic right-wingness by its own centre-right leaders. For a grand coalition to be constructed there are going to have to be compromises, mostly on our relationship with Europe; but there are solutions to finding agreement through our Parliament and constitution that are ours to use and the electorate's to settle, without any permission-seeking from Brussels, just as is done in Italy and Germany. Also the mitbestimmung contribution to Germany's economic success must find its English transformation and place in our 're-balancing' of our economy. The federation of the four countries that make up the United Kingdom needs 're-balancing' too, with parliaments for each and federal relationships more respectful of the interests and cultures of our constituent parts.
There is no place for Brown in any of this; he has betrayed our sane interest for his entire political life, let alone his thirteen years in office. Those to the right of centre can vote for the Conservatives, those who are social democrats will divide between Liberals and Labour, but all of us must be aware that Brown has no interest in bowing to electoral withholding of his mandate, nor capacity to build what we all want, and need, to emerge from the disaster he has made.
Our first objective must be to vote Brown from office, any office, for he can make no contribution to political life nor can anything he stands for.
Friday, 16 April 2010
Nothing to Do With Right or Left, but Right or Wrong
The Guardian is reporting that Brown Labour is lamenting the leaking of its economists' letter. That puts 'leaks' into perspective. Anyone who can put BSc(Econ) after their name has had a copy.
Its content is hardly rocket science, more like warmed over greens from the Cambridges of the 1960s (and earlier); so there would be economists who disagree, wouldn't there? Nothing to do with right wing or left wing, either - some of those signatories are distinguished, and others are even more distinguished by their right wing stance.
Its content is hardly rocket science, more like warmed over greens from the Cambridges of the 1960s (and earlier); so there would be economists who disagree, wouldn't there? Nothing to do with right wing or left wing, either - some of those signatories are distinguished, and others are even more distinguished by their right wing stance.
Just Looking
David Cameron's decision to let the party leader televised debates take place has yielded a prize: a public measure of just how much damage Brown is doing to the Labour party. Not just damage from a display of petulance, inappropriate body language, lying, and unprovoked aggression coupled with transparent (or should that be trans-paaar-ent, in his peculiar pronunciations of standard English?) brown-nosing of a man he has been insulting for years, which under-scored his personal inadequacies of character and personality; but an hour and a half-long warning that the Labour he leads, a reflection, a composite, of his repellent self, has no intention of pausing in its destruction of our country's economic independence or democratic system. And if the goal of staying in power while delivering the UK into the beggary and thuggery of corporatism requires dishonesty displayed in every word, twitch , and lick of Clegg, he's the man for the job.
While the Liberal Democrat (well, Social Democrat really, there's nothing Liberal about the shirleywilliamsyness of the Labour schismatics led by Clegg) displayed the attractive 'let's be reasonable about things, we've got to put our differences aside and pull together for a fair society, decent jobs, a nice house, continental holidays, and pretty clothes', the toad agreed:
'As Nick says, we must have all those things...'
Clegg should remember the Punch cartoon from the last time the Liberals were asked by Labour "Are you going my way?" The electorate must remove Brown before there can be any rapprochement, or reunification of the centre left in England.
While the Liberal Democrat (well, Social Democrat really, there's nothing Liberal about the shirleywilliamsyness of the Labour schismatics led by Clegg) displayed the attractive 'let's be reasonable about things, we've got to put our differences aside and pull together for a fair society, decent jobs, a nice house, continental holidays, and pretty clothes', the toad agreed:
'As Nick says, we must have all those things...'
Clegg should remember the Punch cartoon from the last time the Liberals were asked by Labour "Are you going my way?" The electorate must remove Brown before there can be any rapprochement, or reunification of the centre left in England.
Thursday, 15 April 2010
Croydonian (as was) Crowd Sources the Election
Chiswickite is
'looking at the current state of betting over at Betfair, and based on the shortest odds, I am calling results for [each part of the country]' .
Amazing, so different from the political sampling being offered.
'looking at the current state of betting over at Betfair, and based on the shortest odds, I am calling results for [each part of the country]' .
Amazing, so different from the political sampling being offered.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



