In most societies, in most of time, the status of women is defined by their unique ability to bear children. That ability extends beyond conception and childbirth. Bearing children doesn't begin to be encompassed wholly in those two acts; socially, and probably biologically, motherhood rests with us for life. And our children's lives too will embody our motherhood, whatever form it has taken. Including our absence.
Men who choose life partners in marriage who are men choose also relationships with the mother for any children born into such marriages. There are cultures where the inability to bear children (including those where no female is available in the correct marriage kinship category) is met with various solutions, concubinage being the most common and, once, widely accepted. Now even concubinage is displaced by an outright denial of any special natural link between mother and child in surrogacy. Surrogacy does not have the minimal social elaborations and protections afforded to concubinage.
Gay marriage strips away the socially-constructed but naturally-generated statuses that motherhood confers on women. Usually, and in all current same-sex marriage institutional arrangements, surrogate-birth women are denied any social role engendered by natural requirements. If surrogate-birth women do have any social statuses proffered to them these are entirely within the gift of the gay spouses. Payment extinguishes any rights in motherhood for both mother and child in gay marriage even if, occasionally and entirely one-sidedly, other arrangements are set up.
The proponents of gay marriage are not demanding equal status with marriage. They are seeking the cancellation of what many would see as the purpose of marriage: the procreation of children and the social affirmation of the status of women as equal partners in their creation and upbringing.
Sunday, 26 May 2013
Friday, 24 May 2013
Pressure to Re-think the European Union Still Coming from Italy's Largest Single Parliamentary Gouping
"The European Union should be re-thought. We are planning an information year [on the current European Union] and then instigating a referendum on Yes or No to the Euro and Yes or No to the European Union. The English are teaching us democracy. No party may arrogate the right to decide for 60 million people."*
The Five Star Movement has taken up again its central electoral campaign policy of putting the destruction of Italy's economy and democracy by the European Union's elites to direct democratic vote. This, of course, is the cause of the savage exclusion - at any constitutional and ethical cost - of the largest, single, elected group in the Italian Parliament from power.
Expect the amputation of the ability to impose a binding referendum by the submission of half a million peoples' signatures; either by the extra-Parliamentary committee of appointed constitutional 'experts' acting through the Constitutional Court, or a declaratory law from the presidentially-imposed Executive, in the near future.
*L’Europa va ripensata. Noi consideriamo di fare un anno di informazione e poi di indire un referendum per dire sì o no all’Euro e sì o no all’Europa». «Sull’Euro e sull’Europa gli inglesi ci insegnano la democrazia. Nessun partito può arrogarsi il diritto di decidere per 60 milioni di persone».
The Five Star Movement has taken up again its central electoral campaign policy of putting the destruction of Italy's economy and democracy by the European Union's elites to direct democratic vote. This, of course, is the cause of the savage exclusion - at any constitutional and ethical cost - of the largest, single, elected group in the Italian Parliament from power.
Expect the amputation of the ability to impose a binding referendum by the submission of half a million peoples' signatures; either by the extra-Parliamentary committee of appointed constitutional 'experts' acting through the Constitutional Court, or a declaratory law from the presidentially-imposed Executive, in the near future.
*L’Europa va ripensata. Noi consideriamo di fare un anno di informazione e poi di indire un referendum per dire sì o no all’Euro e sì o no all’Europa». «Sull’Euro e sull’Europa gli inglesi ci insegnano la democrazia. Nessun partito può arrogarsi il diritto di decidere per 60 milioni di persone».
Thursday, 23 May 2013
On Returning to Italy and Leaving Democratic Civilisation
It's barely worth writing about the installation of dictatorship in Italy; all the usual suspects from the highest to the lowest, all the ususal excuses about emergency and temporary and experts and technicians and Europe. So take it as read that Italy is a representative democracy only in name, as were the countries of the East, and the countries of the past under Fascism and Communism.
Never and then never will direct popular democracy be permitted to operate the levers of power, no matter how large our group in Parliament nor how formally constitutionally guaranteed. The sensation of wanting to vomit reading and listening to the usual suspects' mellifluous self- righteousness or peremptory condemnation of populism and non-party movements is longstanding and widespread. "You haven't understood" charming and capable Italians of various backgrounds and sophisticated skills and statuses would tell me as I enthused over formally democratic rights and obligations. I have now.
Just as an example in a multitude of repressive measures being introduced, no political grouping not formally composed into a political party conforming to hierarchical organisational structures and with a juridical personality will be permitted to stand for Parliament; nor will such a grouping be able to access any state political funding for propaganda or for election expenses (it is a source of distaste that any grouping, party or no, should have access to tax-payer funding, but let that pass, as the scandal of the intertwined banks and parties must be allowed to pass).
The internet is now policed and condemnation of people and policies is defined as insult: criticism is permitted, the definition of which is left open to the complainant or the authorities. Behaviour during the 20th century is not to be considered relevant - re-opening old wounds not being conducive to the imposition of the national peace.
Unemployment is described as youth unemployment though what is youthful about being 40 and without work? Never worked? This is infantilisation and policy-driven removal of basic economic and social activities. Of a piece with the destruction of political and civic claims and deriving from the same source - European policies and governance structures.
Any threat to these last will be met with a response that breaks any rule, denies any choices, permits any authoritarian outrage. The images of demonstrators from the Milan social centres being beaten with truncheons are up there with the squadristi.
The response of civilised Italians is as it has ever been: the rientro nel privato - the withdrawal into private worlds mediated by networks of friendship and kinship - of the established, the carefully orchestrated emigration of the younger generation to education and work in the rest of the world until return is needed by this private world.
"We told you," say those from the prestigious English and American universities, from international institutions, from well-to-do lifestyles of unblemished propriety, from firms and industries insulated from the economic disaster by a kind of economic version of this self-defence against pillaging elites.
After three weeks in London the engulfing criminality and pseudo-justification of democratic perversion on coming back here makes England's equivocating with a continued membership of the European Union look irresponsible. There is nothing for England in membership of the European Union. There is no reform, no return of powers, nothing to be renegotiated. The kind of renegotiation outlined by David Cameron denies the foundation and purpose of the European Union.
Leave. Leave while your sins and failures are still, just, your own. You don't want what we've got.
Never and then never will direct popular democracy be permitted to operate the levers of power, no matter how large our group in Parliament nor how formally constitutionally guaranteed. The sensation of wanting to vomit reading and listening to the usual suspects' mellifluous self- righteousness or peremptory condemnation of populism and non-party movements is longstanding and widespread. "You haven't understood" charming and capable Italians of various backgrounds and sophisticated skills and statuses would tell me as I enthused over formally democratic rights and obligations. I have now.
Just as an example in a multitude of repressive measures being introduced, no political grouping not formally composed into a political party conforming to hierarchical organisational structures and with a juridical personality will be permitted to stand for Parliament; nor will such a grouping be able to access any state political funding for propaganda or for election expenses (it is a source of distaste that any grouping, party or no, should have access to tax-payer funding, but let that pass, as the scandal of the intertwined banks and parties must be allowed to pass).
The internet is now policed and condemnation of people and policies is defined as insult: criticism is permitted, the definition of which is left open to the complainant or the authorities. Behaviour during the 20th century is not to be considered relevant - re-opening old wounds not being conducive to the imposition of the national peace.
Unemployment is described as youth unemployment though what is youthful about being 40 and without work? Never worked? This is infantilisation and policy-driven removal of basic economic and social activities. Of a piece with the destruction of political and civic claims and deriving from the same source - European policies and governance structures.
Any threat to these last will be met with a response that breaks any rule, denies any choices, permits any authoritarian outrage. The images of demonstrators from the Milan social centres being beaten with truncheons are up there with the squadristi.
The response of civilised Italians is as it has ever been: the rientro nel privato - the withdrawal into private worlds mediated by networks of friendship and kinship - of the established, the carefully orchestrated emigration of the younger generation to education and work in the rest of the world until return is needed by this private world.
"We told you," say those from the prestigious English and American universities, from international institutions, from well-to-do lifestyles of unblemished propriety, from firms and industries insulated from the economic disaster by a kind of economic version of this self-defence against pillaging elites.
After three weeks in London the engulfing criminality and pseudo-justification of democratic perversion on coming back here makes England's equivocating with a continued membership of the European Union look irresponsible. There is nothing for England in membership of the European Union. There is no reform, no return of powers, nothing to be renegotiated. The kind of renegotiation outlined by David Cameron denies the foundation and purpose of the European Union.
Leave. Leave while your sins and failures are still, just, your own. You don't want what we've got.
Monday, 13 May 2013
Blogger Persecution Underway in Italy
22 commenters on Beppo Grillo's blog have been charged with “Offesa all’onore e al prestigio del Presidente della Repubblica". The comments, which are described as extremely damaging to the honour and prestige of Giorgio Napolitano, were posted a year ago and have been the object of investigation by the Polizia Postale* and involve bloggers throughout Italy as well as those using servers abroad.
The minister of Justice in the Letta/Berlusconi/Napolitano administration (formerly minister of the Interior in the Monti/Napolitano administration) gave the go-ahead for the charges reports Il Fatto Quotidiano. Prosecutors in an evenly spread net across Italy will now be taking forward the proceedings, doubtless aided by their postal collaborators.
*Postal Police? How many kinds of police does Italy have? They must have the ten o'clock police and even the eleven o'clock police who come and get you if you're still in your jamas.
The minister of Justice in the Letta/Berlusconi/Napolitano administration (formerly minister of the Interior in the Monti/Napolitano administration) gave the go-ahead for the charges reports Il Fatto Quotidiano. Prosecutors in an evenly spread net across Italy will now be taking forward the proceedings, doubtless aided by their postal collaborators.
*Postal Police? How many kinds of police does Italy have? They must have the ten o'clock police and even the eleven o'clock police who come and get you if you're still in your jamas.
Wednesday, 8 May 2013
Democracy Denied in Major European Union States
That the European Union has no further historic purpose is an understanding whose time has come. Germany is reunited - which was the primary objective of the immediate post-War original institutions - and, more importantly, no Europeans are going to permit the use of their terrain as battle fields again.
The European Projecteers are engaged in a wholly different and now collapsing plan. Where 'plan' is the operative word - they want a centrally planned federal state, redistributive and 'fair' with all the disastrous incompetencies that brought down the last attempt, under realised socialism, to be resolved by informational and technological innovation. None of which has anything to do with the unification of Germany except insofar as unification brought a definitive end to the failed attempt in the East.
When Nigel Lawson acknowledges that whatever European unity might have been it is now utterly inappropriate for the United Kingdom to subject itself to its present and future intentions he does not even bring into the argument the sheer unpleasantness of some of its Member States. Current and developing unpleasantness, that is, never mind their pasts.
Italy's new status as a presidential dictatorship is a malignant sore on the face of a democratic Europe. Its democratic political system has collapsed under the assault of an authoritarian statist egomaniac who still believes; whose age and acculturation, coupled with obdurate persistence in ideological and ethical wrongdoing has brought corruption of the soul. The United Kingdom cannot continue in any kind of political association with a Europe accepting Member-States like Italy.
The European Projecteers are engaged in a wholly different and now collapsing plan. Where 'plan' is the operative word - they want a centrally planned federal state, redistributive and 'fair' with all the disastrous incompetencies that brought down the last attempt, under realised socialism, to be resolved by informational and technological innovation. None of which has anything to do with the unification of Germany except insofar as unification brought a definitive end to the failed attempt in the East.
When Nigel Lawson acknowledges that whatever European unity might have been it is now utterly inappropriate for the United Kingdom to subject itself to its present and future intentions he does not even bring into the argument the sheer unpleasantness of some of its Member States. Current and developing unpleasantness, that is, never mind their pasts.
Italy's new status as a presidential dictatorship is a malignant sore on the face of a democratic Europe. Its democratic political system has collapsed under the assault of an authoritarian statist egomaniac who still believes; whose age and acculturation, coupled with obdurate persistence in ideological and ethical wrongdoing has brought corruption of the soul. The United Kingdom cannot continue in any kind of political association with a Europe accepting Member-States like Italy.
Tuesday, 30 April 2013
Roses and Young Girls
The European Central Bank, under Mario Draghi, is looking like the Italian Constitution under Giorgio Napolitano - malleable. Germany swapped the Deutschmark for the euro in return for German reunification and the setting-up of a European central bank modelled on the Bundesbank; indeed the ECB was to be the Bundesbank writ large. What was not to like in the founding pillar of the West German state becoming the founding pillar of a united Germany, and of the European Union as a whole?
No, the Germans said, the ECB would not be answerable to Ecofin. "the single currency, under the authority of the Central Bank would complete monetary union, while economic union would merely consist of national policies, coordinated by the Council of Economic and Finance Ministers. " The Delors Report would not be implemented.
Well, it's looking as if the Italians are going to have a sly try. Not the whole thing, of course, out of the question. But this 'austerity is not enough, Europe needs fiscal measures and debt-sharing and common economic policies and growth, and so say all of us except you Germans and your selfish northern goody-goodies' mantra is accompanied by the ECB's Mario Draghi pushing the mandate of the ECB as out of shape as his country's poor Constitution. European Central Bank independence is becoming a double-edged sword. Germany et al., needs to assert not just independence but the religious observance by the ECB of its mandate under the treaties; which brings us to Charles de Gaulle's assessment of treaties - they last while they last.
No, the Germans said, the ECB would not be answerable to Ecofin. "the single currency, under the authority of the Central Bank would complete monetary union, while economic union would merely consist of national policies, coordinated by the Council of Economic and Finance Ministers. " The Delors Report would not be implemented.
Well, it's looking as if the Italians are going to have a sly try. Not the whole thing, of course, out of the question. But this 'austerity is not enough, Europe needs fiscal measures and debt-sharing and common economic policies and growth, and so say all of us except you Germans and your selfish northern goody-goodies' mantra is accompanied by the ECB's Mario Draghi pushing the mandate of the ECB as out of shape as his country's poor Constitution. European Central Bank independence is becoming a double-edged sword. Germany et al., needs to assert not just independence but the religious observance by the ECB of its mandate under the treaties; which brings us to Charles de Gaulle's assessment of treaties - they last while they last.
Sunday, 28 April 2013
Saturday, 27 April 2013
Germany Has Outgrown the Project as Italy Scrambles to Get the European Central Bank Up and Running with OMT
It is crucial for the European Project to get an Italian administration in place, an interlocutor for the European Central Bank, before the Bundesbank puts the boot into Mario Draghi. The ins and outs of democratic impropriety being explored by the Italian nomenklatura are of interest only to the nerds of political imposition and its means, idiosyncratic to each state system, and no longer matter anyway
As the Italian administration members are announced 2.3 trillion euros of Italian sovereign debt remains, as it always has been, the reef for the euro, and for the European Union that has tried to fix its own particular form for ever, via a common currency. All the other eurozone states in sovereign debt crisis are a nuisance but not a systemic threat to the single currency and thus to the European Project - the 'tying-down-Germany-into-the-Europe-that-suits-us-the-victors' Europe. Of course, Italy has always been a problem for Germany: it has a long, long tail of criminal, pre-modern governance attached to the continental north by nationalist concerns and, perhaps as importantly, it has a deep-rooted refusal to confront its 20th century history and confess, as Germany has done. So it's quite a cheek for Italy to be still attempting a holier than thou attitude to Germany (it was an outrage during the last century) and try to use the Project to shove its debt onto German (and other member-states') taxpayers. This administration is probably too late to activate OMT.
On balance Italy does not bring enough to a German-dominated European Union which is bound together by a common currency that is acceptable to modern Germany. Indeed Italy and the aging Project is a constant threat to Germany's complex relations to the East and the Balkans and a threat, via its debt, to the central pillar and the political consensus of the German state.
Germany has sloughed-off the Project and is now building another Europe. Hence the closing-down of German acceptance of the European Central Bank and its variously-clothed attempts to saddle Germany with the debt, and all the corruption that debt represents, of others; particularly Italian others (most of whom have no claim to ethical or political superiority over the Germany of either the last century or this. It's no good Italy going about singing Bella Ciao at the tops of their voices, they were all at it, and many of them still are - 88 indeed).
So while Italy's current (and in some cases erstwhile) elites are in part trying to justify their present behaviour by a long out-dated need to cage a long-ago Germany, modern Germany is going to cut them and their Central Bank Italian off at the knees. Frankly, Germany has bigger fish to fry and other roles to play. Italy has allowed its elites from the past, and its myths and self justifications of the past to dominate its present and its people. It's looking as if we're going to be left to stew in our own debt. And the euro, its zone, and it's outdated Project are only for peripheral people.
Giorgio Napolitano hasn't noticed, but he's out of time, imposed administration or no.
As the Italian administration members are announced 2.3 trillion euros of Italian sovereign debt remains, as it always has been, the reef for the euro, and for the European Union that has tried to fix its own particular form for ever, via a common currency. All the other eurozone states in sovereign debt crisis are a nuisance but not a systemic threat to the single currency and thus to the European Project - the 'tying-down-Germany-into-the-Europe-that-suits-us-the-victors' Europe. Of course, Italy has always been a problem for Germany: it has a long, long tail of criminal, pre-modern governance attached to the continental north by nationalist concerns and, perhaps as importantly, it has a deep-rooted refusal to confront its 20th century history and confess, as Germany has done. So it's quite a cheek for Italy to be still attempting a holier than thou attitude to Germany (it was an outrage during the last century) and try to use the Project to shove its debt onto German (and other member-states') taxpayers. This administration is probably too late to activate OMT.
On balance Italy does not bring enough to a German-dominated European Union which is bound together by a common currency that is acceptable to modern Germany. Indeed Italy and the aging Project is a constant threat to Germany's complex relations to the East and the Balkans and a threat, via its debt, to the central pillar and the political consensus of the German state.
Germany has sloughed-off the Project and is now building another Europe. Hence the closing-down of German acceptance of the European Central Bank and its variously-clothed attempts to saddle Germany with the debt, and all the corruption that debt represents, of others; particularly Italian others (most of whom have no claim to ethical or political superiority over the Germany of either the last century or this. It's no good Italy going about singing Bella Ciao at the tops of their voices, they were all at it, and many of them still are - 88 indeed).
So while Italy's current (and in some cases erstwhile) elites are in part trying to justify their present behaviour by a long out-dated need to cage a long-ago Germany, modern Germany is going to cut them and their Central Bank Italian off at the knees. Frankly, Germany has bigger fish to fry and other roles to play. Italy has allowed its elites from the past, and its myths and self justifications of the past to dominate its present and its people. It's looking as if we're going to be left to stew in our own debt. And the euro, its zone, and it's outdated Project are only for peripheral people.
Giorgio Napolitano hasn't noticed, but he's out of time, imposed administration or no.
One Last Heave for Napolitano
As the Italian collaborators stitch-up an administration they are, also and inevitably, creating the Opposition. And the Opposition in Italy has constitutional roles (not that constitutional guarantees exist any more, of course, but they do have to go through the motions to obliterate them and that does take time). Among those roles is the chair of the state broadcasting company, the RAI, and the chair of the state security commission, COPASIR.
If the Opposition is made up of more than one party then the chair is elected by a simple majority of the Opposition MPs. The Five Stars have an enormous, absolute majority in the Opposition. It doesn't matter that minor parties of the collaborationists are declaring themselves as part of the Opposition - Five Stars has 163 MPs. It has been obvious since the election last February that if the Democratic Party could not split Five Stars and assimilate a large enough part of the Stellar Movement into an administration-supporting role then there was a huge threat to not just the Italian political elites.
Accessing the files (and horrors) of COPASIR state intelligence by a political Movement based on internet and local association, entirely without party structures to act as gate-keepers to political information and power, would pale Wikileaks and the publication of the secret intelligence files of the German Democratic Republic into insignificance (and the GDR has been abolished, unlike Italy and its local, European, and gobal elites).
Imagine - the state intelligence authority and the state broadcasting authority in Five Stars' irreverent hands. Come on Giorgio Napolitano! You're the vecchio, glorioso comunista - Italy and the world needs the smack of firm, authoritarian governance in this above all else.
If the Opposition is made up of more than one party then the chair is elected by a simple majority of the Opposition MPs. The Five Stars have an enormous, absolute majority in the Opposition. It doesn't matter that minor parties of the collaborationists are declaring themselves as part of the Opposition - Five Stars has 163 MPs. It has been obvious since the election last February that if the Democratic Party could not split Five Stars and assimilate a large enough part of the Stellar Movement into an administration-supporting role then there was a huge threat to not just the Italian political elites.
Accessing the files (and horrors) of COPASIR state intelligence by a political Movement based on internet and local association, entirely without party structures to act as gate-keepers to political information and power, would pale Wikileaks and the publication of the secret intelligence files of the German Democratic Republic into insignificance (and the GDR has been abolished, unlike Italy and its local, European, and gobal elites).
Imagine - the state intelligence authority and the state broadcasting authority in Five Stars' irreverent hands. Come on Giorgio Napolitano! You're the vecchio, glorioso comunista - Italy and the world needs the smack of firm, authoritarian governance in this above all else.
Thursday, 25 April 2013
Not Going to Prison is Not Enough
Silvio Berlusconi wants his conviction, and his possible conviction overturned and stopped. Then he wants a constitutional revolution in which the Head of State is directly elected to be the political leader of the country, as in the French Fifth Republic. And he wants it now because convicted criminals are excluded from political office, and because he's old, though not as old as our current Head of State (who he plans to succeed and who could fall off the twig anytime.)
In the recent ructions he's managed, as part of their settling down, to have the hearing confirming his conviction and four-year prison sentence halted while earlier parts of the conduct of the case are reviewed and, he hopes, a ruling sets aside the conviction, after which the statute of limitations will once more ride to his rescue as any fresh trial is cut off mid stride. As for Bunga-Bunga and under-age prostitution, well that's already halted as he's too important and busy a politician to be disturbed by having to go to court while he's fixing up his future (there's some high falutin' legal language for this but effectively it's 'not going to court because too busy').
So, he gets what he wants now and, to keep us all quiet we get our property taxes back and are promised never again - or he pulls the plug on Wormtongue and we all vote on the beaches - when the offer of our property taxes back and a promise never to do it again will beckon (even now the polls are very much in favour).
It's either Berlusca is let off the hook and given a presidency to stand for or the Stability and Growth Pact.
In the recent ructions he's managed, as part of their settling down, to have the hearing confirming his conviction and four-year prison sentence halted while earlier parts of the conduct of the case are reviewed and, he hopes, a ruling sets aside the conviction, after which the statute of limitations will once more ride to his rescue as any fresh trial is cut off mid stride. As for Bunga-Bunga and under-age prostitution, well that's already halted as he's too important and busy a politician to be disturbed by having to go to court while he's fixing up his future (there's some high falutin' legal language for this but effectively it's 'not going to court because too busy').
So, he gets what he wants now and, to keep us all quiet we get our property taxes back and are promised never again - or he pulls the plug on Wormtongue and we all vote on the beaches - when the offer of our property taxes back and a promise never to do it again will beckon (even now the polls are very much in favour).
It's either Berlusca is let off the hook and given a presidency to stand for or the Stability and Growth Pact.
Wednesday, 24 April 2013
Italy Precipitating Towards a General Election
The "vecchio, glorioso comunista" (88) who admonished us all in mouth-filling Togliatti-speak while swearing at the Italian Parliament has now told the media to be quiet and do its bit for the stitch-up under Silvio Berlusconi's right-hand-man's nephew - or he will resign.
So it's as we were, really. No government - because Bersani's deputy is no more use than Bersani in delivering a united governing party; and no Head of State because he's on the brink of resignation twenty-four hours into a seven year mandate he is wholly unequipped to fulfil; and with the outgoing prime minister, Mario Monti, having just altered the wording of his final decree to embed irreversibly a property tax demanded by the European Union to bring Italy into line with pan-eurozone (and EU) tax measures, despite the abolition of taxes on wealth, particularly main residence wealth, being the cornerstone of Berlusconi's policies.
The newly-elected governor of Friuli-Venezia-Giulia (Renzi-party) has arrived in Rome to confront the Democratic Party with their refusal to vote for Rodota' as President even as they agreed to vote for Berlusconi in government (or at least part of the Party did).
We are all going to the seaside shortly, until September, so the general election will have to be in October. That will coincide nicely with general elections in Germany.
So it's as we were, really. No government - because Bersani's deputy is no more use than Bersani in delivering a united governing party; and no Head of State because he's on the brink of resignation twenty-four hours into a seven year mandate he is wholly unequipped to fulfil; and with the outgoing prime minister, Mario Monti, having just altered the wording of his final decree to embed irreversibly a property tax demanded by the European Union to bring Italy into line with pan-eurozone (and EU) tax measures, despite the abolition of taxes on wealth, particularly main residence wealth, being the cornerstone of Berlusconi's policies.
The newly-elected governor of Friuli-Venezia-Giulia (Renzi-party) has arrived in Rome to confront the Democratic Party with their refusal to vote for Rodota' as President even as they agreed to vote for Berlusconi in government (or at least part of the Party did).
We are all going to the seaside shortly, until September, so the general election will have to be in October. That will coincide nicely with general elections in Germany.
Wormtongue Appointed in Italy
Giuliano Amato, arriving in Rome to open a new exhibition he has curated on Niccolo' Machiavelli, has expressed his satisfaction at the appointment of Enrico Letta, stand-in leader of the Democratic Party after Pierluigi Bersani's resignation, as Prime Minister-elect.
Letta requires a vote of confidence in both Houses of Parliament to confirm his administration.
Letta requires a vote of confidence in both Houses of Parliament to confirm his administration.
'Meglio un morto in casa che un Pisano all'uscio' as they say in Florence.
Tuesday, 23 April 2013
Looking on the Bright Side in Italy
We had received such a tongue-lashing for the last 17 months - public debt over 130% of GDP, tax take far too low, punishment by the markets, irresponsible behaviour and lack of civic pride, international scorn, private selfishness over-riding the public good.....on and on went the elites and the political establishment to the point we were getting sheepish and even considering owning up to these charges.
Napolitano II has saved the day. All the media say he has saved the day, both here and abroad. We must draw lessons from his behaviour: no need to follow the rules, rules have been set aside because of the crisis; our ethical and political stances must embrace the ethical and political stances of those who look to Berlusconi as their embodiment; pragmatic agreement and implementation of compromise on, well, almost everything really, is the act of the good citizen. We must consider our situation and act accordingly, regardless of rules, codes, higher things.
Italians have been returned to our existential comfort zone.
Napolitano II has saved the day. All the media say he has saved the day, both here and abroad. We must draw lessons from his behaviour: no need to follow the rules, rules have been set aside because of the crisis; our ethical and political stances must embrace the ethical and political stances of those who look to Berlusconi as their embodiment; pragmatic agreement and implementation of compromise on, well, almost everything really, is the act of the good citizen. We must consider our situation and act accordingly, regardless of rules, codes, higher things.
Italians have been returned to our existential comfort zone.
Monday, 22 April 2013
Rome Empty as Napolitano II Parades Through the City
Napolitano II progressed through a Rome totally silent apart from occasional performances of the better-known parts of the national anthem by various military bands. Not a soul turned up to acclaim his presidency. Monumental Rome treated the military ceremonial with contempt, and Napolitano II was accompanied only by his European Union catspaw Mario Monti and the heavy security guard, after delivering an ill-tempered, ill-mannered harangue before Parliament after being sworn-in.
Better than being sworn at, presumably, but that will come after the courtesy of silence extended to the office he has occupied today.
Better than being sworn at, presumably, but that will come after the courtesy of silence extended to the office he has occupied today.
Who Would Want Office in Napolitano's Puppet Government?
Giuliano Amato has publicly expressed his distaste at the instrumentalisation of his name by various political factions within the political parties that make up the Italian political establishment during the run-up to the elections for head of state.
Professor Amato is quintessentially a European statesman. How much more distasteful must he find, then, the persistent association of his name - as potential appointee of the disgraceful Napolitano stitch-up - with prime minister in the puppet government about to be imposed.
Angels cannot believe that such an esteemed political scientist, jurist and constitutionalist would touch such 'office', such a presidency, with a barge-pole.
Professor Amato is quintessentially a European statesman. How much more distasteful must he find, then, the persistent association of his name - as potential appointee of the disgraceful Napolitano stitch-up - with prime minister in the puppet government about to be imposed.
Angels cannot believe that such an esteemed political scientist, jurist and constitutionalist would touch such 'office', such a presidency, with a barge-pole.
Sunday, 21 April 2013
Grabbing Power
The Italian Constitutional Court should have ruled on the
validity of a renewed candidature to the presidency of Italy. The
Italian Constitution rests on more than one pillar: there is the
codification in the text; there is precedent; there are court
rulings; there is interpretation by distinguished scholars incorporated
in re-castings of the code; there is the history of the constitution
itself which brings with it the precedent and rulings and
interpretations of the constitution/s on which it draws or has been
modelled; then there is the influence of supra-national law and many
other influences that any constitutionalist will list.
Suffice it to say that the Italian Constitution does not exist solely in a text . Even less so does it exist in a vacuum - it is, and must be, part of democracy which derives from many and deeply-rooted sources, both in time and in space.
Thus to watch the democratic charade enacted yesterday in the Italian Parliament was very painful. Certainly the democratic procedures of voting were pompously observed - but the doubtful legitimacy of the candidature remained unaddressed. Only the Constitutional Court is constitutionally and technically equipped to address the legitimacy of the candidature of a sitting president to his own succession.
For a start Napolitano 1 is in office until 15 May, his powers constitutionally and deliberately weakened in the last 6 months of that office. Napolitano 2 is over-riding that constitutional provision by taking office tomorrow. Has Napolitano 1 resigned? Or are we to have two presidents as we have two popes? The fact that the man is the same person does not extinguish the provisions made to prevent the inappropriate use of presidential powers at the end of a presidency. Nor does the fact that the code is silent imply that other constitutional resources do not forbid a candidature we are expected to endorse in the name of some greater good.
Rules matter. Without them there is no democracy.
UPDATE
It has just been announced that Napolitano has 'formally resigned' from the presidency prior to the swearing-in ceremony this afternoon. So if Italy means to declare war anytime between now and half past five this evening it'll be the Speaker of the Senate who does it. More important matters, such as reaching for power outside the constitutional mandate are, however, continuing apace under Napolitano's own steam.
Suffice it to say that the Italian Constitution does not exist solely in a text . Even less so does it exist in a vacuum - it is, and must be, part of democracy which derives from many and deeply-rooted sources, both in time and in space.
Thus to watch the democratic charade enacted yesterday in the Italian Parliament was very painful. Certainly the democratic procedures of voting were pompously observed - but the doubtful legitimacy of the candidature remained unaddressed. Only the Constitutional Court is constitutionally and technically equipped to address the legitimacy of the candidature of a sitting president to his own succession.
For a start Napolitano 1 is in office until 15 May, his powers constitutionally and deliberately weakened in the last 6 months of that office. Napolitano 2 is over-riding that constitutional provision by taking office tomorrow. Has Napolitano 1 resigned? Or are we to have two presidents as we have two popes? The fact that the man is the same person does not extinguish the provisions made to prevent the inappropriate use of presidential powers at the end of a presidency. Nor does the fact that the code is silent imply that other constitutional resources do not forbid a candidature we are expected to endorse in the name of some greater good.
Rules matter. Without them there is no democracy.
UPDATE
It has just been announced that Napolitano has 'formally resigned' from the presidency prior to the swearing-in ceremony this afternoon. So if Italy means to declare war anytime between now and half past five this evening it'll be the Speaker of the Senate who does it. More important matters, such as reaching for power outside the constitutional mandate are, however, continuing apace under Napolitano's own steam.
Negotiations Underway
Meetings are now underway in Rome to impose an administration after the Italian general election in February got out of hand. Congratulations on his election by the majority cross-coalition Elites Party in Parliament were expected to open the discussions, after the Party Congress yesterday gave a standing ovation to President Napolitano (88).
[Isn't that Berlin? Never mind, same old...., ed.]
[Isn't that Berlin? Never mind, same old...., ed.]
Game, Set, Match Berlusconi
Snatching defeat from the jaws of victory the majority party from last February's general election has: resuscitated Berlusca's political power; saved him from judicial retribution; restored his status as Leader of the Right; failed to form a government and, indeed, facilitated the installation of a government of the european political elites; failed to stand up for working people in Italy, silencing the trades unions in the process with undelivered and now undeliverable pacts on wages and conditions; and put in office an eighty-eight-year-old man [eighty-seven and three-quarters, ed.] with the institutional bit between his teeth, for a seven-year term.
Silvio Berlusconi has also broken the centre-left with a vivid, televised demonstration of how many of the Democratic Party are actually his MPs - the former Leader of the Democratic Party put the number at one in four of those MPs elected as Democrats and then resigned.
Silvio Berlusconi has also broken the centre-left with a vivid, televised demonstration of how many of the Democratic Party are actually his MPs - the former Leader of the Democratic Party put the number at one in four of those MPs elected as Democrats and then resigned.
Saturday, 20 April 2013
A Frightening Prospect Emerges
To press Giorgio Napolitano to stand for re-election, as factions within the Democratic Party are now doing is to open Pandora's box. The words being used, 'Continue in office at least until the institutional and political crisis is resolved...' ignore constitutional and political reality.
There is no provision for 'extending' a president's seven-year term. A president can stand for election again but none have done so, none have been encouraged to do so, despite willingness on the part of various presidents in the past. The reason is made plain by the shennanigans of the past few days (months?, years?) Every president is elected in, shall we say idiosyncratic circumstances, capable of unexpected outcomes. Ask Romano Prodi. Giorgio Napolitano's election was by means distasteful to many and by a narrow simple majority on the fourth ballot.
Were he to stand again and fail, as Prodi failed, the delegitimisation of his time in office would be immediate. It is bad enough already; despite media attempts at beatification Napolitano is widely disliked for his politicization of the Presidency and is now recognised as a profoundly polarising head of state. A united Europe and the unity of Italy based on the state redistribution of wealth and power to the South from the North are not uncontentious goals.
Napolitano needs to get out of the kitchen.
UPDATE
After Berlusconi's coalition refused to vote at all in the elections to the Presidency of Italy both today and yesterday, and the Democratic party voted blank, at the fifth attempt to elect a head of state, Giorgio Napolitano has agreed to stand again. Unsurprisingly there is insistence on the secrecy of the ballot being waived and the Democratic Party electors will have their votes traced. Unsurprisingly but disgracefully, that is. We are watching the formalisation of dictatorship here.
Further UPDATE
The coalition of Berlusconi, Bersani, Monti, and Moroni has elected Giorgio Napolitano as Head of State in Italy. President Napolitano is 88.
There is no provision for 'extending' a president's seven-year term. A president can stand for election again but none have done so, none have been encouraged to do so, despite willingness on the part of various presidents in the past. The reason is made plain by the shennanigans of the past few days (months?, years?) Every president is elected in, shall we say idiosyncratic circumstances, capable of unexpected outcomes. Ask Romano Prodi. Giorgio Napolitano's election was by means distasteful to many and by a narrow simple majority on the fourth ballot.
Were he to stand again and fail, as Prodi failed, the delegitimisation of his time in office would be immediate. It is bad enough already; despite media attempts at beatification Napolitano is widely disliked for his politicization of the Presidency and is now recognised as a profoundly polarising head of state. A united Europe and the unity of Italy based on the state redistribution of wealth and power to the South from the North are not uncontentious goals.
Napolitano needs to get out of the kitchen.
UPDATE
After Berlusconi's coalition refused to vote at all in the elections to the Presidency of Italy both today and yesterday, and the Democratic party voted blank, at the fifth attempt to elect a head of state, Giorgio Napolitano has agreed to stand again. Unsurprisingly there is insistence on the secrecy of the ballot being waived and the Democratic Party electors will have their votes traced. Unsurprisingly but disgracefully, that is. We are watching the formalisation of dictatorship here.
Further UPDATE
The coalition of Berlusconi, Bersani, Monti, and Moroni has elected Giorgio Napolitano as Head of State in Italy. President Napolitano is 88.
Friday, 19 April 2013
Secretary of Italian Democratic Party Resigns: Pierluigi Bersani Out After Romano Prodi Defeated
The Secretary of the Partito Democratico and 'candidate premier', Pierluigi Bersani, has resigned, as has the President of the Democratic Party, Rosy Bindi. A meeting of the Grand Electors of the centre-left this evening is trying to decide what to do after inflicting a major humiliation on the founder of the Party, the former European Union Commission President Romano Prodi, in failing to deliver enough votes for a simple majority in the elections to the Italian Presidency (over 100 too few). Prodi is reported to be livid.
Italy now has no President and no elected government. Good thing it's the weekend. Tomorrow morning at 10am there is the fifth ballot for the Presidency and half the electorate has no candidate. Silvio Berlusconi has offered to provide a short list from which the Left can choose.
Italy now has no President and no elected government. Good thing it's the weekend. Tomorrow morning at 10am there is the fifth ballot for the Presidency and half the electorate has no candidate. Silvio Berlusconi has offered to provide a short list from which the Left can choose.
Prodi Fails To Be Elected By Over 100 Votes
Despite the Grand Electors of the centre-right - the Berlusconi coalition and the Regions of the Right, withdrawing from the Chamber without voting, Romano Prodi has been humbled by the Bersani faction of the Democratic Party acting as if they are the Communist Party of Italy using all the tactics that belonged with that Party.
While the Five Star Movement and Monti's Scelta Civica voted for their nominees in disciplined fashion, over 50 Democrats broke ranks, voting for Rodota', Cancellieri, and D'Alema as well.
Will Pierluigi Bersani finally resign after his second imposed candidate fails even to get a simple majority?
UPDATE
Romano Prodi has withdrawn his candidacy for the Presidency.
Further UPDATE
Romano Prodi has now called for the resignation of Bersani, reports La Repubblica:
"Chi mi ha portato a questa decisione deve farsi carico delle sue responsabilità." ["Those who brought me to this decision must bear their responsibilities."]
Romano Prodi was the founder of the centre-left Partito Democratico.
While the Five Star Movement and Monti's Scelta Civica voted for their nominees in disciplined fashion, over 50 Democrats broke ranks, voting for Rodota', Cancellieri, and D'Alema as well.
Will Pierluigi Bersani finally resign after his second imposed candidate fails even to get a simple majority?
UPDATE
Romano Prodi has withdrawn his candidacy for the Presidency.
Further UPDATE
Romano Prodi has now called for the resignation of Bersani, reports La Repubblica:
"Chi mi ha portato a questa decisione deve farsi carico delle sue responsabilità." ["Those who brought me to this decision must bear their responsibilities."]
Romano Prodi was the founder of the centre-left Partito Democratico.
A Prodi Presidency Would be a Disaster for Italy and Its Working People
Romano Prodi must be an unacceptable candidate for President of Italy to any Grand Elector of the real Left i.e, the Left that represents working people, not the intellectual bourgeois Left that amuses itself playing cultural politics.
The European Union's economic policies are the ruin of working people in many Member States. These policies require internal devaluation, certainly in all those States that are inside the Eurozone and in others that are still, by their rules of accession, candidate Eurozone members.
Internal devaluation is the polite term for lowering the standard of living of working people. Specifically it targets working people rather than rentiers. It lowers real wages, raises indirect taxes, reduces the social wage, produces unemployment as a means of labour discipline. It is being applied across Europe. It makes Angels weep, never mind the representatives of working people. Prodi is on record as saying that the European Stability and Growth pact is "stupid", but never has he acted to limit the damage it does to working people's lives.
So why is the Democratic Party, repository of the hopes for defence against all this, supported by the organisations of the working people (even corrupted as they are by ideologies and idiocies of centuries past) trying to get an architect of working people's misery made President?
The European Union's economic policies are the ruin of working people in many Member States. These policies require internal devaluation, certainly in all those States that are inside the Eurozone and in others that are still, by their rules of accession, candidate Eurozone members.
Internal devaluation is the polite term for lowering the standard of living of working people. Specifically it targets working people rather than rentiers. It lowers real wages, raises indirect taxes, reduces the social wage, produces unemployment as a means of labour discipline. It is being applied across Europe. It makes Angels weep, never mind the representatives of working people. Prodi is on record as saying that the European Stability and Growth pact is "stupid", but never has he acted to limit the damage it does to working people's lives.
So why is the Democratic Party, repository of the hopes for defence against all this, supported by the organisations of the working people (even corrupted as they are by ideologies and idiocies of centuries past) trying to get an architect of working people's misery made President?
Parliamentary Rinascimento
The presidency of Italy has a fixed seven-year term. Elections for the next president now can hardly have come as a surprise to the Politburo of the Democratic Party, yet it presses for putting-off the vote today to allow time for reflection. Meanwhile regional offices of the Party are being occupied by infuriated Party members from one end of the Peninsula to the other, and Party cards are burning in front of the Parliament's Lower House.
Yesterday's two votes left Politburo plans in ruins as the Democratic Party Grand Electors to the presidency defected en masse to vote for Rodota', the Five Star Movement's candidate. The Democrats lost their coalition partners and almost half their own MPs - not a loss that could be dismissed as 'dissidents' though, pathetically, some tried.
Notable in yesterday's two votes was the compact, disciplined voting of Berlusconi's People of Liberty and their coalition parties, the Lega Nord particularly. Berlusconi always delivers (though we often disapprove of what). What he delivered yesterday was the demolition of the Left.
This morning's vote is the last requiring a two thirds majority for victory (this is supposed to be a co-operative and conciliatory procedure choosing an institutional office-holder who represents the unity of Italy and guaranteeing the system of governance, but the malevolence and viciousness of the political infighting - a fascination of itself - reveals 'victory' is what is being sought) after which a simple majority will suffice.
The expected candidates for this afternoon's vote are:
Franco Marini (who refuses to stand down despite failing at both ballots yesterday, with his 'supporters' polling blank ballots in vote number 2 after he was over 150 votes short in the first vote);
Massimo D'Alema (former leader of the Communist Party of Italy);
Romano Prodi (for the European Union);
Stefano Rodota' (5 Star Movement and Democratic Party rank and file candidate)
The television pictures of the Chamber of the Lower House are mesmerising. To vote the electors worm their way through polished wooden Anderson shelters, emerging from the curtains at the end looking as if they've been through one of those re-birthing experiences used in alternative therapy procedures. Angels suspect it is affecting their voting behaviour.
UPDATE
Franco Marini has withdrawn
Anna Maria Cancellieri, the Monti government's Home Secretary, has been nominated by Monti in the name of a policy of widest possible agreement on candidates. Berlusconi's coalition is evaluating their response.
Massimo D'Alema hasn't said a word on his candidature.
Romano Prodi is reported to be coming back from Africa tomorrow.
Stefano Rodota' is still the candidate of 5 Stars and Solidarity at least for the 3rd ballot (now counting).
Yesterday's two votes left Politburo plans in ruins as the Democratic Party Grand Electors to the presidency defected en masse to vote for Rodota', the Five Star Movement's candidate. The Democrats lost their coalition partners and almost half their own MPs - not a loss that could be dismissed as 'dissidents' though, pathetically, some tried.
Notable in yesterday's two votes was the compact, disciplined voting of Berlusconi's People of Liberty and their coalition parties, the Lega Nord particularly. Berlusconi always delivers (though we often disapprove of what). What he delivered yesterday was the demolition of the Left.
This morning's vote is the last requiring a two thirds majority for victory (this is supposed to be a co-operative and conciliatory procedure choosing an institutional office-holder who represents the unity of Italy and guaranteeing the system of governance, but the malevolence and viciousness of the political infighting - a fascination of itself - reveals 'victory' is what is being sought) after which a simple majority will suffice.
The expected candidates for this afternoon's vote are:
Franco Marini (who refuses to stand down despite failing at both ballots yesterday, with his 'supporters' polling blank ballots in vote number 2 after he was over 150 votes short in the first vote);
Massimo D'Alema (former leader of the Communist Party of Italy);
Romano Prodi (for the European Union);
Stefano Rodota' (5 Star Movement and Democratic Party rank and file candidate)
The television pictures of the Chamber of the Lower House are mesmerising. To vote the electors worm their way through polished wooden Anderson shelters, emerging from the curtains at the end looking as if they've been through one of those re-birthing experiences used in alternative therapy procedures. Angels suspect it is affecting their voting behaviour.
UPDATE
Franco Marini has withdrawn
Anna Maria Cancellieri, the Monti government's Home Secretary, has been nominated by Monti in the name of a policy of widest possible agreement on candidates. Berlusconi's coalition is evaluating their response.
Massimo D'Alema hasn't said a word on his candidature.
Romano Prodi is reported to be coming back from Africa tomorrow.
Stefano Rodota' is still the candidate of 5 Stars and Solidarity at least for the 3rd ballot (now counting).
Thursday, 18 April 2013
Terms of the Italian Stitch-Up?
The suggestion that the only way to give Berlusconi a 'safe conduct' from his various legal difficulties is that he should be made a senator for life has been mooted. To match this breath-taking impertinence, Romano Prodi will also be appointed a life senator. All this, of course, if the 'approved' candidate of the Democratic party and the People of Liberty Party is elected to the Presidency and Bersani is given the premiership (or at least a try at it). The President appoints senators for life. There are, conveniently, two vacancies.
Former Prime Minister Prodi's view on all this is not known.
Former Prime Minister Prodi's view on all this is not known.
An Insult to Italy
An 80 year old, white, male, former trade union leader whose prosecution for corruption during the 1990s was halted only by a refusal of the parliamentary commission of the day to lift his parliamentary immunity has been nominated by the Democratic Party leadership politburo as the candidate agreed between Bersani and Silvio Berlusconi for the office of Head of State in Italy.
Angels assume this proposal is a means of discovering just how bad is the collapse of discipline within the Democratic Party and between the Party's coalition members. Unfortunately the patent inappropriateness of the nomination has shattered the loyalty even of those who were hanging in there with the Bersani leadership through thick (and thick is the word for him and them) and thin (and there are even fewer of them now). A cornered Bersani has made this the vote of confidence in his leadership without regard to the cost it imposes on the country. "I have matters of my own to deal with," he is reported as saying. A triumphant Berlusconi has heaped mealy-mouthed praise upon the candidature he has forced upon Bersani. So far the only thing he hasn't praised Franco Marini for is that he too is a victim of 'politicized justice'.
The Democratic Party's principal ally - Solidarity, Ecology, Liberty - is voting for the candidate of the Five Stars. Chosen after on-line primaries, Stefano Rodota' is a jurist of outstanding competence and a noted defender of civil liberties - though he too is white, male and eighty years old. Originally we had chosen a fearlessly investigative, female journalist in her fifties but she refused the nomination, saying despite the honour her skills were not those needed in the Presidency - an honesty and self-awareness that only confirmed what a great woman she is. So the Five Stars went with the jurist who came in third; second, a wholly estimable surgeon working in theatres of war to help victims of minefields and drone-strikes, asked too that the nomination go to Rodota' as the better qualified for the role of president.
The Mayor of Florence, Matteo Renzi, who leads the sane wing of the Democratic Party has called the Bersani politburo's nomination an insult to the country. Voting starts in Parliament at 10am.
UPDATE
Franco Marini is now unable to achieve two thirds of the vote at the first count.
The People of Liberty party are calling for a change of tactics by Berlusconi.
The Lega Nord agreed to vote for Marini only on the first ballot.
Almost certainly other blocs of votes for Marini, such as the Monti Civic List will start to fragment at the second ballot, which also requires a two thirds majority.
As the dirty details of the stitch-up between Berlusconi and Bersani emerge the Democratic Party is breaking up.
Further UPDATE after the second ballot.
No-one elected. Marini now abandoned although he has not withdrawn his candidature.
The coalition Berlusconi/Bersani/Monti vote blank ballots. The expectation is the same tactic will be used at the next ballot then, when a simple majority suffices, a new candidate will be wheeled out.
The Democratic Party has split in two.
Cold loathing seems to be the order of the day.
Angels assume this proposal is a means of discovering just how bad is the collapse of discipline within the Democratic Party and between the Party's coalition members. Unfortunately the patent inappropriateness of the nomination has shattered the loyalty even of those who were hanging in there with the Bersani leadership through thick (and thick is the word for him and them) and thin (and there are even fewer of them now). A cornered Bersani has made this the vote of confidence in his leadership without regard to the cost it imposes on the country. "I have matters of my own to deal with," he is reported as saying. A triumphant Berlusconi has heaped mealy-mouthed praise upon the candidature he has forced upon Bersani. So far the only thing he hasn't praised Franco Marini for is that he too is a victim of 'politicized justice'.
The Democratic Party's principal ally - Solidarity, Ecology, Liberty - is voting for the candidate of the Five Stars. Chosen after on-line primaries, Stefano Rodota' is a jurist of outstanding competence and a noted defender of civil liberties - though he too is white, male and eighty years old. Originally we had chosen a fearlessly investigative, female journalist in her fifties but she refused the nomination, saying despite the honour her skills were not those needed in the Presidency - an honesty and self-awareness that only confirmed what a great woman she is. So the Five Stars went with the jurist who came in third; second, a wholly estimable surgeon working in theatres of war to help victims of minefields and drone-strikes, asked too that the nomination go to Rodota' as the better qualified for the role of president.
The Mayor of Florence, Matteo Renzi, who leads the sane wing of the Democratic Party has called the Bersani politburo's nomination an insult to the country. Voting starts in Parliament at 10am.
UPDATE
Franco Marini is now unable to achieve two thirds of the vote at the first count.
The People of Liberty party are calling for a change of tactics by Berlusconi.
The Lega Nord agreed to vote for Marini only on the first ballot.
Almost certainly other blocs of votes for Marini, such as the Monti Civic List will start to fragment at the second ballot, which also requires a two thirds majority.
As the dirty details of the stitch-up between Berlusconi and Bersani emerge the Democratic Party is breaking up.
Further UPDATE after the second ballot.
No-one elected. Marini now abandoned although he has not withdrawn his candidature.
The coalition Berlusconi/Bersani/Monti vote blank ballots. The expectation is the same tactic will be used at the next ballot then, when a simple majority suffices, a new candidate will be wheeled out.
The Democratic Party has split in two.
Cold loathing seems to be the order of the day.
Sunday, 14 April 2013
Electing a Head of State Italian Style
The Italian Constitution dedicates 8 articles (83-91) to the election, duties and removal of the head of state. The paucity of powers conferred reflects the negative experiences of Fascist government.
Electorate
The head of state electorate is summoned by the Speaker of the Lower House. The electorate consists of both Houses of Parliament sitting in common session together with 3 representatives from each of the Italian Regions with the exception of the Val d'Aosta which has one. Regional representatives are elected by Regional Councils, normally 2 from the ruling group and one from the opposition, although other 'Grand Electors' are not excluded formally.
Voting Rules
Of those present and voting a two thirds majority is required for election on the first few ballots. After that a simple majority will suffice. Only two heads of state have succeeded on one of the first two ballots since the Second world war. Some elections have dragged on for up to two weeks.
Qualifications
Candidates must be over 50 years old, Italian citizens, and in full possession of their civil and political rights. It is possible to be re-elected but no-one ever has been despite lots of former heads of state being only too eager to stay on. No other post, public or private, may be held by the head of state, nor may the head of state undertake any other professional activity.
Taking Office
Office begins at the swearing-in ceremony immediately after the term of the previous office-holder expires, and lasts for seven years.
Substitutes
No vice-presidential office exists. Should the head of state be unable to function for whatever temporary reason the president of the Senate steps in.
Status
Threaten, or even make rude remarks about the honourability of the head of state, and the high jump awaits. In instances of the head of state's high treason or assault upon the Italian Constitution Parliament will bring accusations after a joint sitting and then bring the head of state before the Constitutional Court. This has never happened despite sore provocation on various occasions. The head of state cannot be tried for decisions taken during office pertaining to official duties.
Powers
Every act of office by the head of state must be counter-signed by either the appropriate minister responsible in the government of the day or by the prime minister, except when the head of state acts in the the three duties specifically indicated by the Constitution:
- that of President of the Supreme Defence Council
- that of President of the Superior Council of Magistrates
- that of representing national unity [lot of room there, ed.]
The head of state can send back to Parliament legislation which raises doubts on its constitutional propriety or which has no financial cover. [Eyebrows raised at this point may attract the penalties mentioned above on honour and rude remarks, which certainly includes gestures. ed.]
The head of state nominates Life Senators of which there seems to be a general agreement that half a dozen or so is the limit, at least no head of state has yet tried making so many as to alter the balance of political power in a perfectly bi-cameral Parliament. The head of state can send warning messages to the Parliament that it is misbehaving; nominates constitutional judges, which last power is at the crux of Silvio Berlusconi's current political operations. The head of state can dissolve the Parliament within the parliamentary five-year term when no-one is able to command a majority, except when in the last six months of the seven-year presidential office [in which Napolitano has been since November. ed.]
The head of state nominates the prime minister, either after a general election or when an administration falls to votes of no confidence in Parliament, after consultations with the speakers of both Houses of Parliament and the political parties.
The current Head of State has nominated no-one to face the Parliament since the general election last February. On any actions the current Head of State has undertaken since that election, other than those noted above, the Italian Constitution is silent.
Friday, 12 April 2013
Living in the Past
"The BBC is considering broadcasting a clip of the 1939 song and having a
reporter explain why it is in the top spot. “Many 16 to 24-year-olds are too
young to remember when Lady Thatcher was in office,” a source said.", reports the Telegraph this morning.
It's a scary thought that some 16 to 24-year-olds are not too young to remember Margaret Thatcher's years in office - time-lords perhaps. In Italy we have some 16 to 24-year-old partigiani, indeed many such partisan time-lords are even into their seventies, and they have songs from the 1930s too, with vivid, life-informing experience of fighting for freedom from the Fascists, despite losing their enemy in 1943. Unfortunately these experiences do not inform or engage them in fighting current forms of statist authoritarianism, or even in fighting the eurozone Germans - that's the trouble with being a time-lord, you get stuck in a past irrelevant to an understanding of today's society.
I blame it on their parents.
It's a scary thought that some 16 to 24-year-olds are not too young to remember Margaret Thatcher's years in office - time-lords perhaps. In Italy we have some 16 to 24-year-old partigiani, indeed many such partisan time-lords are even into their seventies, and they have songs from the 1930s too, with vivid, life-informing experience of fighting for freedom from the Fascists, despite losing their enemy in 1943. Unfortunately these experiences do not inform or engage them in fighting current forms of statist authoritarianism, or even in fighting the eurozone Germans - that's the trouble with being a time-lord, you get stuck in a past irrelevant to an understanding of today's society.
I blame it on their parents.
Wednesday, 10 April 2013
Morality and the President of Italy
The President of Italy, lips thrust forward in 'considered' statement, hands in preachyness, is the outward expression of his inward grace. He has chosen to condemn those 'moral fanatics' who 'ruin politics'.
That'll be us. Our insistence that politics should not be funded from taxes, that no parliamentarian should bear other office, that those condemned by the courts should not be eligible for election, that 'expenses' should be backed by paid receipts, that the Legislature, in Parliament should function forthwith regardless of inter-party struggle over the Executive, that Monti has no further mandate, that it is the primary task of the Head of State to nominate prime ministers until someone commands a majority in both Houses, that we do not condone last-gasp pardons for definitively convicted Americans who practice Rendition in the streets of Milan - thus undermining the Judiciary by ultra vires Executive act, our requirement that those who cannot fulfil the role of head of State should resign to make way for someone who can, that at the very least an end could come to mouthing falsity and lies in the interests of dead objectives from half a century ago; our insistence that the Head of State should not subject the interests of Italy and its people to the interests of the European Union's elites - that'll be us, the electorate and our so inconvenient morality ruining the 'politics' of an ill-spent political life.
That'll be us. Our insistence that politics should not be funded from taxes, that no parliamentarian should bear other office, that those condemned by the courts should not be eligible for election, that 'expenses' should be backed by paid receipts, that the Legislature, in Parliament should function forthwith regardless of inter-party struggle over the Executive, that Monti has no further mandate, that it is the primary task of the Head of State to nominate prime ministers until someone commands a majority in both Houses, that we do not condone last-gasp pardons for definitively convicted Americans who practice Rendition in the streets of Milan - thus undermining the Judiciary by ultra vires Executive act, our requirement that those who cannot fulfil the role of head of State should resign to make way for someone who can, that at the very least an end could come to mouthing falsity and lies in the interests of dead objectives from half a century ago; our insistence that the Head of State should not subject the interests of Italy and its people to the interests of the European Union's elites - that'll be us, the electorate and our so inconvenient morality ruining the 'politics' of an ill-spent political life.
Tuesday, 9 April 2013
Monday, 8 April 2013
1976 Is a Very Long Time Ago Mr President
The dictatorship under Napolitano continues. The Head of State has still not made the slightest effort to appoint a prime minister to face Parliament. The Monti 'administration' continues to issue decrees without authority to do so under this Parliament and goes as far as Brussels to receive the European Union blessing for his extra-constitutional efforts. The group of unconstitutional advisors continues to fulfil, as they recognise, their true function of simply wasting time.
Napolitano has just been on television exhorting us to display the 'spirit of 1976' - what spirit? He was eulogising the 20th anniversary of the death of some old communist I'd never heard of who must have somehow distinguished himself (in doubtless particularly repellent fashion). If it wasn't so pathetic it might be unnerving. Immediately after his appearance Margaret Thatcher appeared on the screen in a brief resume of her political life. What a contrast between a major politician and this 87 year old president who is unfortunately still with us.
Tomorrow Parliament is to be occupied by its MPs in a further attempt to initiate parliamentary democratic governance. Currently the Speaker of the Lower House is in accord with setting going the Parliamentary Committees needed to activate parliamentary process. The former communist who is the Speaker of the Senate won't hear of it. Perhaps the reading of the Constitution might stir his brains into recognising the position he's getting himself into.
Napolitano has just been on television exhorting us to display the 'spirit of 1976' - what spirit? He was eulogising the 20th anniversary of the death of some old communist I'd never heard of who must have somehow distinguished himself (in doubtless particularly repellent fashion). If it wasn't so pathetic it might be unnerving. Immediately after his appearance Margaret Thatcher appeared on the screen in a brief resume of her political life. What a contrast between a major politician and this 87 year old president who is unfortunately still with us.
Tomorrow Parliament is to be occupied by its MPs in a further attempt to initiate parliamentary democratic governance. Currently the Speaker of the Lower House is in accord with setting going the Parliamentary Committees needed to activate parliamentary process. The former communist who is the Speaker of the Senate won't hear of it. Perhaps the reading of the Constitution might stir his brains into recognising the position he's getting himself into.
Thursday, 4 April 2013
Bersani and Berlusconi Unite to Prevent the Functioning of the Italian Parliament
The pretence that the Democratic Party will not act politically with the Berlusconi's centre right coalition to form a government is wholly undermined by the reality that the two parties are acting together to prevent the Parliament from working. Ever since MPs were declared elected (which took long enough) even now the two coalitions of Left and Right refuse to allow what the largest single party - the 5 Stars Movement - is seeking: the putting into operation of the various Parliamentary Commissions from which legislation is generated. Parliamentary rules require that each Commission have a chair and vice chair. Without a government, say Bersani and Berlusconi (tacitly recognising that the Monti left-over is no government) those offices cannot be filled. Actually they can; in precisely the kind of hiatus we have now there is provision for the most senior Commission member to act as chair (and since when has anybody been paying the slightest regard to the rules in this fiasco of ad hoc governance?).
There is a grand coalition alright, or rather a common front - keep the 5 Stars Movement away from the levers of power is its bedrock, secret negotiation and agreements its means. Just as Beppe Grillo said it would be. Except that the strain of the exclusion imperative, of freezing out our Movement, is tearing the coalitions apart, particularly Bersani's coalition. Matteo Renzi's MPs are calling for central parts of the 5 Stars programme to be enacted, particularly the removal of all public funding from political parties; the far Left rainbows SEL are joining with the 5 Stars for the immediate initiation of the Commissions' work, indeed it is SEL that has pointed to the means for them to start work immediately.
Napolitano, Berlusconi, and Bersani are horrified at the obvious capacity of the Parliament to work without the control of an Executive. Their problem now is to 'wrap' their alliance sufficiently well to keep their electorates without losing face - and votes - when we go back to the polls.
There is a grand coalition alright, or rather a common front - keep the 5 Stars Movement away from the levers of power is its bedrock, secret negotiation and agreements its means. Just as Beppe Grillo said it would be. Except that the strain of the exclusion imperative, of freezing out our Movement, is tearing the coalitions apart, particularly Bersani's coalition. Matteo Renzi's MPs are calling for central parts of the 5 Stars programme to be enacted, particularly the removal of all public funding from political parties; the far Left rainbows SEL are joining with the 5 Stars for the immediate initiation of the Commissions' work, indeed it is SEL that has pointed to the means for them to start work immediately.
Napolitano, Berlusconi, and Bersani are horrified at the obvious capacity of the Parliament to work without the control of an Executive. Their problem now is to 'wrap' their alliance sufficiently well to keep their electorates without losing face - and votes - when we go back to the polls.
Tuesday, 2 April 2013
Heads of State: Their Failings and Their Splendours
As what looks remarkably like a works' council from Togliattigrad attempts to run Italy the country is without any form of constitutionally sanctioned government. When Elizabeth II asked David Cameron to form a government she didn't do so after five weeks of bad-tempered disbelief at what we had voted for, she didn't appoint a couple of Royal Commissions to set out answers to politico-institutional and socio-economic problems facing the the United Kingdom and add another who knows how long to the wait for a government, she didn't whine that 'the parties have left me isolated'. She didn't hesitate:
Mr Cameron to face Parliament, Mr Brown to vacate Downing Street (and get a move on).
Nor did she visit Italy last month. Didn't feel too well. You wouldn't, would you?
Mr Cameron to face Parliament, Mr Brown to vacate Downing Street (and get a move on).
Nor did she visit Italy last month. Didn't feel too well. You wouldn't, would you?
Monday, 1 April 2013
Mario Monti Should Insist That His Administration Is At An End
Whatever can Mario Monti be thinking of? Why is he lending himself to this anti-democratic farce in Italy? It is one thing to handle matters of everyday administration until the designated majority politician faces the House for a vote of confidence. It is quite another to continue to govern the country when he has not just lost the last elections, he couldn't find the last elections again if he searched for them with both hands. And it is no excuse for apologists to argue that the Constitution places no limits on what is meant by 'everyday administration'. Mario Monti knows perfectly well that he is acting well beyond any commonsense interpretation of those parameters, let alone previous practice which contributes just as much to Italy's written constitution as the words themselves (of necessity, though codified versus non-codified is not the argument of this post).
The Leader of the Democratic Party should face the Parliament. He has the mandate, he has the MPs. If he wins a confidence vote then he's it; if he doesn't then it should be Bersani running a caretaker administration, while new alliances are hurriedly shunted together to have their try, not Mario Monti. If the President of the Republic has not noticed that there is a new Parliament whose confidence Monti does not enjoy, we have. And most certainly Monti has. Monti needs to get up the hill to Napolitano and tell him that's it, the Monti administration is over, tomorrow morning, first thing. Otherwise he's as responsible for what is going on as Napolitano.
The Leader of the Democratic Party should face the Parliament. He has the mandate, he has the MPs. If he wins a confidence vote then he's it; if he doesn't then it should be Bersani running a caretaker administration, while new alliances are hurriedly shunted together to have their try, not Mario Monti. If the President of the Republic has not noticed that there is a new Parliament whose confidence Monti does not enjoy, we have. And most certainly Monti has. Monti needs to get up the hill to Napolitano and tell him that's it, the Monti administration is over, tomorrow morning, first thing. Otherwise he's as responsible for what is going on as Napolitano.
Sunday, 31 March 2013
Time to Ignore the President of Italy and Assert the Sovereignty of Parliament
'In vain I have struggled. It will not do. My feelings will not be repressed.' Angels hold no brief for the Italian Democratic Party or its erstwhile candidate premier. Nonetheless, Pierluigi Bersani has been most seriously wronged, as has the Democratic Party and its voters. It was not for President Napolitano to act as he has. Bersani should meet Parliament and see of he can muster a vote of confidence in both Houses, not have Parliament second-guessed by Napolitano. Italy is not the France of the Fifth Republic (yet).
Bersani has an absolute majority in the Chamber of Deputies (the Lower House). He can table and carry a motion of no confidence in the Monti administration as soon as he likes. At that point Napolitano will be forced to get out of the way, together with his ten Dead White Men, and Bersani will face the Parliament, to be accepted or rejected by the proper body. Bersani has not returned to Napolitano (to Napolitano's reported extreme irritation) the mandate he has held since the President's earlier consultations. With Monti voted out he is freed and, almost certainly, would be able to find the dozen votes he needs in the Senate.
So why doesn't Bersani act? Yes his party is split but for this power-taking operation it might well reunite. Yes a great wound would open in Italian institutions of governance between the Parliament and the Presidency but, frankly, Napolitano has asked for it by putting himself into such a position, and will be gone within weeks anyway. Parliamentary sovereignty should not have been encroached like this. The real reason Bersani won't do it is because he hasn't got the guts Napolitano has, and he's backed down. If Bersani wants office he's got the mandate and the votes but he has to take it.
Bersani has an absolute majority in the Chamber of Deputies (the Lower House). He can table and carry a motion of no confidence in the Monti administration as soon as he likes. At that point Napolitano will be forced to get out of the way, together with his ten Dead White Men, and Bersani will face the Parliament, to be accepted or rejected by the proper body. Bersani has not returned to Napolitano (to Napolitano's reported extreme irritation) the mandate he has held since the President's earlier consultations. With Monti voted out he is freed and, almost certainly, would be able to find the dozen votes he needs in the Senate.
So why doesn't Bersani act? Yes his party is split but for this power-taking operation it might well reunite. Yes a great wound would open in Italian institutions of governance between the Parliament and the Presidency but, frankly, Napolitano has asked for it by putting himself into such a position, and will be gone within weeks anyway. Parliamentary sovereignty should not have been encroached like this. The real reason Bersani won't do it is because he hasn't got the guts Napolitano has, and he's backed down. If Bersani wants office he's got the mandate and the votes but he has to take it.
Ten DWMs
Dead White Males, ten of them have been put in place, personally (as he remarked) by President Napolitano to 'find a solution' to our irresponsible voting at the general election now over a month ago. Actually some of them might not be quite dead but who can tell amongst such an undistinguished cluster of state beneficiaries and eurocrats. No industrialists, no workers, no musicians, no painters, no poets, no sailors, no soldiers, no young, no women - an all-Italian crony-group of an 87 year old man at the end of his powers.
Here they are. Angels can't be bothered to give their individual names. The nomenklatura.
Here they are. Angels can't be bothered to give their individual names. The nomenklatura.
Saturday, 30 March 2013
Anti-democratic Constitutional Garbage
The President of Italy has just got off the telly. He says that the Monti government is remaining because it has never been subject to a vote of no confidence. Monti has offered his resignation but he, Napolitano, has not accepted it. Monti therefore retains the confidence of Parliament and can remain conducting the business of the Italian state.
Unfortunately the Parliament that voted confidence in Senator Monti no longer exists. On 25 February 2013 we elected a new Parliament. Senator Monti does not enjoy the confidence either of this Parliament or of the electorate (who voted him down in droves, he got less than 10% of the vote).
Napolitano is not just off the telly - there are other things he's off as well.
Unfortunately the Parliament that voted confidence in Senator Monti no longer exists. On 25 February 2013 we elected a new Parliament. Senator Monti does not enjoy the confidence either of this Parliament or of the electorate (who voted him down in droves, he got less than 10% of the vote).
Napolitano is not just off the telly - there are other things he's off as well.
Friday, 29 March 2013
Italian Democratic Party May Split in Two and Its Coalition Group Collapse
It was always an uneasy amassing of the Italian Communist Party, the remnants of the Italian Socialist Party, the liberals of the Christian Democrats and various odds and sods left over from debacles in the Italian politics of the last century. Romano Prodi (Christian Democrat) could hold it all together by offering external goals, European agendas that were acceptable to the motley crew. He could attract, too, the votes of the real Centre, the gente perbene of the middle classes repelled by Berlusconi and his behaviours.
Not Bersani: nor could such a grouping be held together by imposition of Communist party discipline, although it could be usurped by Communist party political action and activists - and it has been. The Partito Democratico has never won an election other than under Prodi's leadership and, on Prodi's departure, has lost every time to Berlusconi. Only a minority of Italians are Communist voters. The Communist-faction led PD has lost again this time. This time they kept out the leader who could have given Italy a government over a month ago with their rigged primaries last November. Bersani has argued falsely that only he can keep the PD together. The truth is that only by keeping the PD under its organisational, democratic-centralist thumb can the old Communist Party of Italy survive at all. Since the collapse of the Soviet Union it has had to fund itself via 'foundations' controlling regional banks - notably the Monte dei Paschi, itself now under blanket investigation by the magistrates. Any government installed in Italy other than a Bersani government means the end for the PCI, few followers, no money.
They should be extruded from any party calling itself democratic. They should, together with their 'social forces' - the communist-dominated unions, the third sector, swathes of regional and local government and administration - be finally extinguished as any part of the Left. They put themselves and their survival before country, party, national and local need. They are disloyal to all of these.
Bersani has just said:
"Whoever may come after me.....must first of all win the votes of 480 MPs of our coalition. [because the PD-SEL (far left eco/rainbow party) coalition got 0.4 of the vote more than the Right coalition they received the majority premium in the Lower House, ed.] votes that I have now. So don't come and propose grand coalition government, even disguised behind another name because my "No" is a given already. Half the PD will not vote ever for a sort of new version of the Monti government and does not want to split with the SEL, because SEL will not agree to follow such a path..." [Secretary Bersani often slips into Communist Party-school speech it would be quite funny if it wasn't so vile, ed., emphasis added]
So the other half of the PD will vote how, exactly? For a grand coalition? And how will the SEL then vote once there is nothing to be gained from alliance with the CP rump? By his own admission Bersni can no more hold together Prodi's Democratic Party than fly.
Not Bersani: nor could such a grouping be held together by imposition of Communist party discipline, although it could be usurped by Communist party political action and activists - and it has been. The Partito Democratico has never won an election other than under Prodi's leadership and, on Prodi's departure, has lost every time to Berlusconi. Only a minority of Italians are Communist voters. The Communist-faction led PD has lost again this time. This time they kept out the leader who could have given Italy a government over a month ago with their rigged primaries last November. Bersani has argued falsely that only he can keep the PD together. The truth is that only by keeping the PD under its organisational, democratic-centralist thumb can the old Communist Party of Italy survive at all. Since the collapse of the Soviet Union it has had to fund itself via 'foundations' controlling regional banks - notably the Monte dei Paschi, itself now under blanket investigation by the magistrates. Any government installed in Italy other than a Bersani government means the end for the PCI, few followers, no money.
They should be extruded from any party calling itself democratic. They should, together with their 'social forces' - the communist-dominated unions, the third sector, swathes of regional and local government and administration - be finally extinguished as any part of the Left. They put themselves and their survival before country, party, national and local need. They are disloyal to all of these.
Bersani has just said:
"Whoever may come after me.....must first of all win the votes of 480 MPs of our coalition. [because the PD-SEL (far left eco/rainbow party) coalition got 0.4 of the vote more than the Right coalition they received the majority premium in the Lower House, ed.] votes that I have now. So don't come and propose grand coalition government, even disguised behind another name because my "No" is a given already. Half the PD will not vote ever for a sort of new version of the Monti government and does not want to split with the SEL, because SEL will not agree to follow such a path..." [Secretary Bersani often slips into Communist Party-school speech it would be quite funny if it wasn't so vile, ed., emphasis added]
So the other half of the PD will vote how, exactly? For a grand coalition? And how will the SEL then vote once there is nothing to be gained from alliance with the CP rump? By his own admission Bersni can no more hold together Prodi's Democratic Party than fly.
Thursday, 28 March 2013
Bersani Told to Go Home But He Still Doesn't Understand He Lost the Election
Comrade Bersani has been told by the Head of State that as his proposals for government are not able to command a majority in the Parliament, even on paper, he can't be prime minister. The prime minister remains Mario Monti and the Monti administration remains in office. The President of Italy has stated that he will personally begin consultations to put together a post-Monti administration. Neither the Bersani faction of the Democratic Party nor Bersani himself will accept this and have declared that the Leader will continue in his negotiations for a majority in both Houses of the Italian Parliament.
Bersani doesn't seem to have a proper grasp on how to put together a coalition. It is not done by barking orders at the largest single Party represented in the Lower House, and holding the vital votes in the Upper House, to get back in line or we'll have to have another election. We are quite willing to have another election - after the new President has been elected; the Bersani Democratic faction's attempts to portray the 5 Star Movement as disaffected lefties has just been time-wasting but as the new elections cannot be until June at the earliest (what with one thing and another) it doesn't really matter. Now they understand, 5 Stars is not just an outbreak of indiscipline from the Democrat Party line. Nor is it made up of political innocents or fools. We have an agenda, oh yes.
We were told in a press conference an hour ago that to form a coalition Bersani 'would have had to accept proposals and conditions unacceptable to him.' Poor lamb; he told us what we had to agree to, perfectly plainly. He even wrote it all down for us in eight points but we kept changing them, and requiring so much more - like not financing his party out of tax-payers' money (that was one of the unacceptable conditions). He's demanding to meet Parliament, so clearly he's failed to grasp as well that Italy actually has got a government (admittedly not very popular but wholly efficient) and the President hasn't accepted Monti's resignation (even though he's had it since January) so there isn't a vacancy.
Berlusca's condition for support was himself as the next president of Italy or, if that were thought a touch risque' then his principal political advisor, Gianni Letta, would do it. The Northern Leagues want all taxes raised in northern Italy spent in northern Italy and an autonomous North. You can see that Napolitano had a point, telling Bersani to go home; and it took over an hour to get Bersani out of the Quirinale.
Bersani doesn't seem to have a proper grasp on how to put together a coalition. It is not done by barking orders at the largest single Party represented in the Lower House, and holding the vital votes in the Upper House, to get back in line or we'll have to have another election. We are quite willing to have another election - after the new President has been elected; the Bersani Democratic faction's attempts to portray the 5 Star Movement as disaffected lefties has just been time-wasting but as the new elections cannot be until June at the earliest (what with one thing and another) it doesn't really matter. Now they understand, 5 Stars is not just an outbreak of indiscipline from the Democrat Party line. Nor is it made up of political innocents or fools. We have an agenda, oh yes.
We were told in a press conference an hour ago that to form a coalition Bersani 'would have had to accept proposals and conditions unacceptable to him.' Poor lamb; he told us what we had to agree to, perfectly plainly. He even wrote it all down for us in eight points but we kept changing them, and requiring so much more - like not financing his party out of tax-payers' money (that was one of the unacceptable conditions). He's demanding to meet Parliament, so clearly he's failed to grasp as well that Italy actually has got a government (admittedly not very popular but wholly efficient) and the President hasn't accepted Monti's resignation (even though he's had it since January) so there isn't a vacancy.
Berlusca's condition for support was himself as the next president of Italy or, if that were thought a touch risque' then his principal political advisor, Gianni Letta, would do it. The Northern Leagues want all taxes raised in northern Italy spent in northern Italy and an autonomous North. You can see that Napolitano had a point, telling Bersani to go home; and it took over an hour to get Bersani out of the Quirinale.
Monday, 25 March 2013
Poor Cyprus
Cyprus, being unable to assert its claims to the gas fields around it, has been taken apart. Any state wishing to exploit its natural resources had better have the defence resources to do so, international law and treaties being always a cover story for powerful states, not a guarantee for weak ones. This is true as well for claims by EU bureaucrats that Cyprus is a template for dealing with member states' sovereign debt rule-breaking. Small or weak states will be brought to euro-heel, the others will reshape the euro-structures. Those determined that the euro should succeed must hope for confidence in its flexibility to respond to political change within and between powerful member-states.
Even Spain is too poor, too under-resourced, too under-developed to exert Euro-reformatting. The people there can riot in the streets for all the effect it will have on changing the euro structures or enabling the Spanish government to alter their relationship with the eurozone. In contrast, the United Kingdom, although formally equally bound by euro rules, is big enough and rich enough to ignore them when it chooses. And does. This independence of action is usually attributed to retaining a national currency - undoubtedly a help - but the real source of capacity for self-assertion is the usual: too big and complex an economy and a state too powerful to push around. No EU Projecteers are going to tell France and Germany what to do either. The euro structures will certainly respond to their requirements.
Which leaves Italy. The idea that the treatment of Cyprus could be used as a template for Italy is far-fetched, unless such a template is self-administered. While there can be no Troikerenes flying into Rome to lay down the law, the pitched political battle here is precisely over whether Monti's imposition of the current shape of euro requirements continues, or euro-structures flex to Italian politico-economic pressures. Monti is still prime minister; Napolitano is determined to push the constitution into any shape it takes to keep the current administration - under another name, whatever name - to do from within what weaker states have had forced upon them from without. There is, at the moment, a kind of shadow template that has been introduced by the Monti government. We can all do as we please but every move we make will be reported by various bodies and institutions and subsequently attract investigation that amounts to little more than fiscal and financial harrassment. The President of the Republic and the Prime Minster (who was so humiliatingly rejected at the general election last February) are still trying to leave the current euro-structures alone and warp Italy.
The electorate, disinclined to be impoverished at every level and their economy reduced to, at best, stasis have voted for the re-structuring of the euro and the Union. What happens here should be of much greater interest to the citizens of large, powerful European states than anywhere that has been in the sovereign-debt news so far.
Even Spain is too poor, too under-resourced, too under-developed to exert Euro-reformatting. The people there can riot in the streets for all the effect it will have on changing the euro structures or enabling the Spanish government to alter their relationship with the eurozone. In contrast, the United Kingdom, although formally equally bound by euro rules, is big enough and rich enough to ignore them when it chooses. And does. This independence of action is usually attributed to retaining a national currency - undoubtedly a help - but the real source of capacity for self-assertion is the usual: too big and complex an economy and a state too powerful to push around. No EU Projecteers are going to tell France and Germany what to do either. The euro structures will certainly respond to their requirements.
Which leaves Italy. The idea that the treatment of Cyprus could be used as a template for Italy is far-fetched, unless such a template is self-administered. While there can be no Troikerenes flying into Rome to lay down the law, the pitched political battle here is precisely over whether Monti's imposition of the current shape of euro requirements continues, or euro-structures flex to Italian politico-economic pressures. Monti is still prime minister; Napolitano is determined to push the constitution into any shape it takes to keep the current administration - under another name, whatever name - to do from within what weaker states have had forced upon them from without. There is, at the moment, a kind of shadow template that has been introduced by the Monti government. We can all do as we please but every move we make will be reported by various bodies and institutions and subsequently attract investigation that amounts to little more than fiscal and financial harrassment. The President of the Republic and the Prime Minster (who was so humiliatingly rejected at the general election last February) are still trying to leave the current euro-structures alone and warp Italy.
The electorate, disinclined to be impoverished at every level and their economy reduced to, at best, stasis have voted for the re-structuring of the euro and the Union. What happens here should be of much greater interest to the citizens of large, powerful European states than anywhere that has been in the sovereign-debt news so far.
Thursday, 21 March 2013
No-one Blinking in Berlin, Moscow or Nicosia
The established Russian financial base in Cyprus is under very serious threat from Berlin masked as the EU and from the US masked as the IMF. It is not credible that the Russian government regards the Russian resources in Cyprus as illegal or borderline legal - their size and the entities involved are part of Russian policy even if there are some Russian and non-Russian money laundering advantage-takers in the mix.
The European Central Bank continues to provide liquidity to Cyprus banks. EU rules require it to provide such liquidity only to solvent banks; Cyprus banks are being kept solvent only by the funding that requires their solvency for such funding to be extended. Obviously the ECB is holding the banks in suspension while the political stand-off is resolved (in itself a highly politicised act from an ostensibly 'technical' institution, but then it has its own axe to grind about eurozone member states departing the zone).
Cyprus government (which includes the whole political and cultural spectrum, as do other Mediterranean states, it's the constitutional model used in this part of the world) is entertaining the Troika while its minister of Finance is in Moscow and, he says, intends to stay there until discussions are satisfactorily completed, though what form finalisation will take is under consideration. Meanwhile in Cyprus the parliamentary draftsmen are blamed for no legislation being available for bank resolution and a parliamentary session to debate this is cancelled. The chances of this being true are challenged by Cyprus having perfectly well drafted (by the English) bank resolution legislation, have had since long ago.
The RAF has had to fly out a plane load of euro bank notes because the eurozone seems unable to perform even that most basic of monetary operations, run a retail cash banking system.
Every, perfectly reasonable, alternative to mulcting the Russians out of their deposits and out of such a geo-politically important piece of real estate is met with vetos from the Troikerenes in Nicosia. Pips are going to be made to squeak, right down to the last euro to teach all of us Southern wastrels to mind ourselves as well.
The Archbishop of Cyprus, who owns the third largest bank there, and large pieces of the island, has been seen kissing the new Jesuit Pope in Rome, (Dearest brother) which is giving a decided Umberto Eco-ish twist to these events. The Italian President, occupying Rome's magnificent former papal palace, is failing meanwhile to put together a democratic pro-European administration while the largest single party in the Italian Parliament calls for re-negotiating the euro and, indeed the entire European Project.
The European Central Bank continues to provide liquidity to Cyprus banks. EU rules require it to provide such liquidity only to solvent banks; Cyprus banks are being kept solvent only by the funding that requires their solvency for such funding to be extended. Obviously the ECB is holding the banks in suspension while the political stand-off is resolved (in itself a highly politicised act from an ostensibly 'technical' institution, but then it has its own axe to grind about eurozone member states departing the zone).
Cyprus government (which includes the whole political and cultural spectrum, as do other Mediterranean states, it's the constitutional model used in this part of the world) is entertaining the Troika while its minister of Finance is in Moscow and, he says, intends to stay there until discussions are satisfactorily completed, though what form finalisation will take is under consideration. Meanwhile in Cyprus the parliamentary draftsmen are blamed for no legislation being available for bank resolution and a parliamentary session to debate this is cancelled. The chances of this being true are challenged by Cyprus having perfectly well drafted (by the English) bank resolution legislation, have had since long ago.
The RAF has had to fly out a plane load of euro bank notes because the eurozone seems unable to perform even that most basic of monetary operations, run a retail cash banking system.
Every, perfectly reasonable, alternative to mulcting the Russians out of their deposits and out of such a geo-politically important piece of real estate is met with vetos from the Troikerenes in Nicosia. Pips are going to be made to squeak, right down to the last euro to teach all of us Southern wastrels to mind ourselves as well.
The Archbishop of Cyprus, who owns the third largest bank there, and large pieces of the island, has been seen kissing the new Jesuit Pope in Rome, (Dearest brother) which is giving a decided Umberto Eco-ish twist to these events. The Italian President, occupying Rome's magnificent former papal palace, is failing meanwhile to put together a democratic pro-European administration while the largest single party in the Italian Parliament calls for re-negotiating the euro and, indeed the entire European Project.
Wednesday, 20 March 2013
Greece Considers Re-Opening Close Contacts With Putin
A map of the Mediterranean to hand is useful when reading the news on the Cyprus stand-off. Now it is reported in the Fatto Quotidiano that the Cypriot Finance minister is no longer talking just to his Russian counterpart, and that talks which were originally about extending the Russian loan and reducing its interest rate have now moved to another venue and onto "other matters'. What these might be can be readily guessed and their importance and generality intuited if the further suggestion that Mr Putin has asked the President of Cyprus to come to Moscow is correct.
Meanwhile the Church has intervened to offer its full support to the Cyprus government and points out that it is the largest land owner on the island and wholly disposed to making land available to the state. It suggests also development bonds for the land that would be subscribed down to parish level throughout the island.
Greece too is now wondering if it should seek renewed close contacts with Mr Putin via former Conservative prime minister Costas Karamanlis, whose vision of Greece as an energy hub dovetails with Russian gas delivery via South Stream into Europe and particularly to Italy.
Northern European Union moral hazard nerds are uniting a Southern European community of interest they do not seem to have fully grasped.
Meanwhile the Church has intervened to offer its full support to the Cyprus government and points out that it is the largest land owner on the island and wholly disposed to making land available to the state. It suggests also development bonds for the land that would be subscribed down to parish level throughout the island.
Greece too is now wondering if it should seek renewed close contacts with Mr Putin via former Conservative prime minister Costas Karamanlis, whose vision of Greece as an energy hub dovetails with Russian gas delivery via South Stream into Europe and particularly to Italy.
Northern European Union moral hazard nerds are uniting a Southern European community of interest they do not seem to have fully grasped.
Italian Democratic Party Splits in the Lower House
The Italian President finally opens negotiations for the next administration today, a month after the general election. Unfortunately for the self-seeking Bersani, the Democratic Party has split. In the voting for the Party leadership in the Lower House (the equivalent in the UK would be, more or less, the chief whip) Bersani attempted to foist a candidate onto the assembled Democrat MPs by demanding his candidate be elected 'by acclamation'. As the candidate is a full time, full working life, Bersani faction, Party creep this attempt to close ranks round Bersani himself was met with silence, followed by a request for a secret ballot. Trade union MPs then tried to insist on no ballot. MPs insisted right back. The vote split the Party with a third denying support; as there was only one candidate (nice, democratic, Bersani-ites) ballot papers had to be left blank.
So we now have a third of the Lower House majority Party voting en bloc against the imposed leadership. The comrades tried to explain this unfortunate and very public demonstration of their smaller than they pretend support by claiming the bloc to be supporters of Matteo Renzi but the evidence is that those 87 votes against the leadership came from across the Party political spectrum, united only by their antipathy to the organised proto-communist and trade union faction.
The Head of State is today to be presented by Bersani with 'a unanimously agreed Party programme' and a claim on the premiership. The Democratic Party has no majority in the Upper House and, as has just been shown, no control over all its own members in the Lower.
So we now have a third of the Lower House majority Party voting en bloc against the imposed leadership. The comrades tried to explain this unfortunate and very public demonstration of their smaller than they pretend support by claiming the bloc to be supporters of Matteo Renzi but the evidence is that those 87 votes against the leadership came from across the Party political spectrum, united only by their antipathy to the organised proto-communist and trade union faction.
The Head of State is today to be presented by Bersani with 'a unanimously agreed Party programme' and a claim on the premiership. The Democratic Party has no majority in the Upper House and, as has just been shown, no control over all its own members in the Lower.
How Are We Defining Wealth?
The widely accepted heist on savings over a hundred thousand euros - it's the heist on sums lower than that which mostly is causing the outrage - is unnerving. Wealth taxes should be on wealth not bog standard savings.
Everyone would have their threshold for 'wealth', but a hundred thousand euros? You couldn't buy a studio flat in South Hatfield for a £100,000 (never mind euros.)
Everyone would have their threshold for 'wealth', but a hundred thousand euros? You couldn't buy a studio flat in South Hatfield for a £100,000 (never mind euros.)
Tuesday, 19 March 2013
Whatever It Takes?
Italy is an existential threat to the Euro and to the Union. Just for starters between 71 and 79 billion euros is owed by the Italian state, at national and local levels, to small, medium and even larger businesses. Obviously there will be, and there is, a cascade effect and, as during the Transition of the eastern bloc (with the complicity of the IMF) we have the beginning of the de-monetisation of the Italian economy.
Last week the Prime Minister went to Brussels to obtain authorisation for unblocking at least this disaster, whose cause is not principally lack of funds: regional and local authorities are forbidden to release the funds they have because they are bound by the rules of the Stability and Growth pact. Italy needs to live under fiscal sovereignty. It is also the third largest economy in the EU. Something has got to give. Simply demonising Italians as ne'er-do-well, sun-tanned, ice-cream eaters is beyond good and evil (as the saying goes here).
We tried. We voted. The moment we - finally - got our hands on a ballot (which event was so improperly delayed for 15 months by a President claiming dictatorial powers under constitutional guise) we voted for a re-negotiation, or out of the Euro. Since winning a month ago, no government at all has been installed; the Monti administration is forcibly (though again under constitutional guise) kept in office. Even Mario Monti himself is protesting against his slaving to European Union imperatives. His use of Garibaldi's "Obbedisco" is hardly a full-hearted expression of consent, or of agreement with the Head of State's understanding of our situation, and his objectives for Italy. Napolitano had to swallow Monti's scathing consent because Monti's government is the only possible Italian counter-party for any international bailing - in or out - and there is no possibility of stable democratic governance (for instance, Comrade Bersani has just accused us all of being Leninists, which is a remarkable exposition of his mindset. Angels are not at all sure what a Leninist is, but it must be better than being a Bersani Stalinist. Whatever - it gives an idea of where they are coming from).
Now the Cyprus experiment has made plain the full content of Mario Draghi's 'Do whatever it takes' euro speech. What the euro-zealots intend to take is a sitting duck in the nation's bank accounts. Well, it's a sitting duck at the moment but it's getting under cover fast, despite 15 months of Monti trying to close down escape routes (which attempts, both Monti's and our defensive manoeuvres, of themselves have had adverse effects for investment in a time of broken monetary transmission mechanisms. How pathetic to have driven the country's savers into gold.)
Meanwhile in another part of the forest Silvio Berlusconi, whose coalition received only 100,000 fewer votes than the dominant Bersani-ite Democratic Party, has said plainly that any further constitutional warping of the higher offices of the state will be met with obdurate opposition in Parliament and Piazza (constitutionally Italian government rests upon continuous and cross-party consent much more than the oppositional model of, say, the UK). The Five Stars, who definitely hold 25% (but even 30% according to Italy's latest iffy political polls) of the electorate, are joined at least in the requirement for fresh elections, with Berlusconi. The pro-European elites publish dream teams of 'civic', imposed governance in their media. The Northern Leagues want an end not just to the EU in its present form but to Italy in its present form as well; and these anti-Europe anti- united Italy separatists are the chosen target coalition group Bersani hopes to use to shoe-horn himself into power.
In its current figuration and future goals Europe cannot afford Italy. Indeed Angels are unsure whether Europe can even afford itself. Italy can afford Italy, but we can't afford Europe; not the awful Austrians again, or the Germans either (the Dutch and the Finns are just gloomy coat-tailers from soggy seasides, and frozen wastes at the edge of Russia). If 'Whatever It Takes' means the destruction of Italian manufacturing industry, bankruptcy, the mass unemployment of the young, the denial of the concept of property, and the dismemberment of Italy, this is not for Mario Draghi or President Napolitano to offer. Not for their idea of Europe.
Last week the Prime Minister went to Brussels to obtain authorisation for unblocking at least this disaster, whose cause is not principally lack of funds: regional and local authorities are forbidden to release the funds they have because they are bound by the rules of the Stability and Growth pact. Italy needs to live under fiscal sovereignty. It is also the third largest economy in the EU. Something has got to give. Simply demonising Italians as ne'er-do-well, sun-tanned, ice-cream eaters is beyond good and evil (as the saying goes here).
We tried. We voted. The moment we - finally - got our hands on a ballot (which event was so improperly delayed for 15 months by a President claiming dictatorial powers under constitutional guise) we voted for a re-negotiation, or out of the Euro. Since winning a month ago, no government at all has been installed; the Monti administration is forcibly (though again under constitutional guise) kept in office. Even Mario Monti himself is protesting against his slaving to European Union imperatives. His use of Garibaldi's "Obbedisco" is hardly a full-hearted expression of consent, or of agreement with the Head of State's understanding of our situation, and his objectives for Italy. Napolitano had to swallow Monti's scathing consent because Monti's government is the only possible Italian counter-party for any international bailing - in or out - and there is no possibility of stable democratic governance (for instance, Comrade Bersani has just accused us all of being Leninists, which is a remarkable exposition of his mindset. Angels are not at all sure what a Leninist is, but it must be better than being a Bersani Stalinist. Whatever - it gives an idea of where they are coming from).
Now the Cyprus experiment has made plain the full content of Mario Draghi's 'Do whatever it takes' euro speech. What the euro-zealots intend to take is a sitting duck in the nation's bank accounts. Well, it's a sitting duck at the moment but it's getting under cover fast, despite 15 months of Monti trying to close down escape routes (which attempts, both Monti's and our defensive manoeuvres, of themselves have had adverse effects for investment in a time of broken monetary transmission mechanisms. How pathetic to have driven the country's savers into gold.)
Meanwhile in another part of the forest Silvio Berlusconi, whose coalition received only 100,000 fewer votes than the dominant Bersani-ite Democratic Party, has said plainly that any further constitutional warping of the higher offices of the state will be met with obdurate opposition in Parliament and Piazza (constitutionally Italian government rests upon continuous and cross-party consent much more than the oppositional model of, say, the UK). The Five Stars, who definitely hold 25% (but even 30% according to Italy's latest iffy political polls) of the electorate, are joined at least in the requirement for fresh elections, with Berlusconi. The pro-European elites publish dream teams of 'civic', imposed governance in their media. The Northern Leagues want an end not just to the EU in its present form but to Italy in its present form as well; and these anti-Europe anti- united Italy separatists are the chosen target coalition group Bersani hopes to use to shoe-horn himself into power.
In its current figuration and future goals Europe cannot afford Italy. Indeed Angels are unsure whether Europe can even afford itself. Italy can afford Italy, but we can't afford Europe; not the awful Austrians again, or the Germans either (the Dutch and the Finns are just gloomy coat-tailers from soggy seasides, and frozen wastes at the edge of Russia). If 'Whatever It Takes' means the destruction of Italian manufacturing industry, bankruptcy, the mass unemployment of the young, the denial of the concept of property, and the dismemberment of Italy, this is not for Mario Draghi or President Napolitano to offer. Not for their idea of Europe.
Monday, 18 March 2013
Cyprus Achieves Full Communism
In the good old Soviet days goods' prices were held down artificially but the goods were not there. The population accumulated useless cash unwillingly. The government tried to capture these involuntary savings by making obligatory the purchase of government bonds. Those were not savings but a form of taxation. However the Soviet government never got round to actually confiscating excess cash except a couple of times in the 1950s by enforcing a currency conversion at progressively more punitive rates for prices, bank accounts, and cash. As they used to say, under full Communism there would still be money for some but not for others.
The European Union has succeeded in reconstructing Soviet-type confiscation of hard-earned savings because setting limits to cash withdrawals have turned part of household savings into forced involuntary savings. In Cyprus, by then skimming depositors' accounts at a very high rate, they have been recognised by Medvedev (not unnaturally) for what they are. There is no difference between Soviet practice then and European Union practice today.
The European Union has succeeded in reconstructing Soviet-type confiscation of hard-earned savings because setting limits to cash withdrawals have turned part of household savings into forced involuntary savings. In Cyprus, by then skimming depositors' accounts at a very high rate, they have been recognised by Medvedev (not unnaturally) for what they are. There is no difference between Soviet practice then and European Union practice today.
Gold Rush
Just running down to the bank - irrational not to, as Mervyn King remarked. It opens at 8.30 but it might be best to get a head start on the rest of the village. Fortunately the bank at the bottom of the hill sells gold bars. It's supposed to be for the local factories but mostly they'll be selling to most of us today.
Sunday, 17 March 2013
Five Stars 1: Berlusca/Bersani 0
The Five Stars promised to rip open the corrupt Parties and their Parliament like a tin of tuna. They have.
It has cost them tears of blood but they have blocked-off so many strategies with the Revolt of the Sicilians (who voted for the anti-Mafia Senate Speaker Grasso, otherwise they couldn't go home) and thus ensured the defeat of both Comrade Bersani's chosen candidate, the scrap-heap-worthy Finocchiaro, and Berlusconi's investigated-for-Mafia-involvement candidate, Schifani. In the process they have demonstrated that they are not Grillo's zombies - one of the principal disdainful attributions of the elites and their media, and discovered the joys of flexing our political muscle.
They have blocked-off the rising Monti-for-President tide; they have lopped-off a Wimmin-for-President Hydra-head and put Finocchiaro back in the scrap; they have cornered the 'Democratic' Party with two purely nominally Democratic institutional posts leaving the Presidency almost unattainable for a third 'Democrat' (there is constitutionally an expectation that senior state positions should be shared across the political spectrum); they have honoured their commitment to vote piece by piece for what their electors want.
The elites and progressive media are screaming that the Five Stars have been split. Rather, at their first passage of arms, they could hardly have done more.
Sadly, Italy has run out of time.
It has cost them tears of blood but they have blocked-off so many strategies with the Revolt of the Sicilians (who voted for the anti-Mafia Senate Speaker Grasso, otherwise they couldn't go home) and thus ensured the defeat of both Comrade Bersani's chosen candidate, the scrap-heap-worthy Finocchiaro, and Berlusconi's investigated-for-Mafia-involvement candidate, Schifani. In the process they have demonstrated that they are not Grillo's zombies - one of the principal disdainful attributions of the elites and their media, and discovered the joys of flexing our political muscle.
They have blocked-off the rising Monti-for-President tide; they have lopped-off a Wimmin-for-President Hydra-head and put Finocchiaro back in the scrap; they have cornered the 'Democratic' Party with two purely nominally Democratic institutional posts leaving the Presidency almost unattainable for a third 'Democrat' (there is constitutionally an expectation that senior state positions should be shared across the political spectrum); they have honoured their commitment to vote piece by piece for what their electors want.
The elites and progressive media are screaming that the Five Stars have been split. Rather, at their first passage of arms, they could hardly have done more.
Sadly, Italy has run out of time.
Italy Now Merely Going Through the Motions
Italy's debt has reached the highest level ever: 2,022.7 billion euros (having risen 34 billion euros since December). The Prime Minister has been ordered not to resign by the President; the powers to do this are non-existent so we must assume that force was applied via the usual 'offer you can't refuse' means, though what this consisted in is not (yet) known publicly.
The Parliament has finally met and Speakers for both Houses have been chosen - for the Lower House a member of the Solidarity, Ecology, Liberty party (who took 3% of the - mad Left - vote) and for the Upper House an anti-Mafia former magistrate (because the other candidate was the previous, Berlusconi, Parliament's Speaker whose anti-mafia credentials leave much to be desired). Both were elected on the fourth, simple majority, ballot; neither have the least idea how they got there and are as surprised as the rest of us by their sudden elevation to the second and third highest offices of the Italian state.
Almost a month since the general election Italy has no government. It's not good enough the President pretending that Mario Monti is in charge, as patently he is not. Senator Monti told the President last week that with the Brussels meeting his term was complete, as are his duties and his competencies. So the only government we have is President Napolitano with most of his presidential powers removed, or in precipitous decline a month before he leaves office, and a protesting Monti who argues (and he argued for over an hour in the presidential palace, with precedents to hand for substitutes and notable vehemence for such a mild-mannered man) that he is not a caretaker, nor a lightning conductor for the raging storm that is all that is left of Italian governance.
Italy is in a constitutional, political and economic catastrophe suspended only by our old friend 'Too Big to Fail'.
The Parliament has finally met and Speakers for both Houses have been chosen - for the Lower House a member of the Solidarity, Ecology, Liberty party (who took 3% of the - mad Left - vote) and for the Upper House an anti-Mafia former magistrate (because the other candidate was the previous, Berlusconi, Parliament's Speaker whose anti-mafia credentials leave much to be desired). Both were elected on the fourth, simple majority, ballot; neither have the least idea how they got there and are as surprised as the rest of us by their sudden elevation to the second and third highest offices of the Italian state.
Almost a month since the general election Italy has no government. It's not good enough the President pretending that Mario Monti is in charge, as patently he is not. Senator Monti told the President last week that with the Brussels meeting his term was complete, as are his duties and his competencies. So the only government we have is President Napolitano with most of his presidential powers removed, or in precipitous decline a month before he leaves office, and a protesting Monti who argues (and he argued for over an hour in the presidential palace, with precedents to hand for substitutes and notable vehemence for such a mild-mannered man) that he is not a caretaker, nor a lightning conductor for the raging storm that is all that is left of Italian governance.
Italy is in a constitutional, political and economic catastrophe suspended only by our old friend 'Too Big to Fail'.
Friday, 15 March 2013
Authoritarian Rule in Italy
The authoritarianism of Italian governance is not attracting as much comment as it might if current goings-on were going on in, say, England. Starting from the top, the President is out of his constitutional cage and rampaging across the democratic terrain wiping out the independence of Judiciary from Executive, refusing reasonable progress in the forming of an administration conforming to the parameters of the last general election, enabling to the bitter end the continuance of the administration he installed (Monti has now been kept in office - control might be a more accurate choice of word - for 16 months) and asserting for himself complete powers to 'resolve' the problem of our 'ungovernability'. Behind the facade of technical or caretaker government there is presidential government ruling by decree and freed now from even the minimal restraint imposed by parliamentary vote.
Moving down, we have the caretaker government itself. Monti is in Brussels at the moment, reporting in on the control of any livelier responses to internal deflation, and the centralised coverage of lapses in systemically important bank/political administration practices.
The disciplining of regional and local level population, business and contracts is suffering too from the advance of 'irresponsible' voting at local level which has been generated by too much troughing by local administrations, their associated institutions, and their personnel. Attention is to be directed to this problem once our hash has been settled at the centre. However the steady attrition resulting from investigation, charge and arrest of local bankers, institutional administrators various, revelations of hospitals, universities, etc., with big black holes in their institutional fabric - and in the case of schools, roads, entire towns and even cities, their physical fabric too - has been noted as both disruptive of smooth rule and encouraging of our uppity tendencies. There are to be fewer occasions of voting (sinful, voting is) once the response to the outcome of the general election - and here it is arguable that the general election in question is that of 2008 and its presidential subversion - has been settled into place permanently; then the reform of local governance can be decreed once more (the previous decrees fell with the arrival of the national quinquennial requirement to let us out of our boxes).
The media generally are under control, distracted by individual stories of iniquity and exploitation of the public purse, and in any case mostly committed to the bog standard systems of political control currently being finalised at European level. In Italy of course they have especially the mythology of fascism (as well as its realities) to attack in all its 20th century wickedness, leaving its 21st century form, shape-shifting and viciously efficient, free run at our lives, culture and, inter alia, our standard of living and our security (both of which last might reasonably be agreed to be part of the state's remit but not the first two).
Pan-European attempts to portray the Five Stars as clowns, innocents, ignoramuses, have given way to defamation and demonisation. We can expect the first criminalisations shortly, extending beyond the media and into the institutions of our dying democracy. Angels doubt we'll be allowed near a ballot box again any time soon, whatever particular form taken by the 'crisis' justifications being put forward by the Euro-regime (the war on terror now being rather old hat and never awfully popular in Europe).
The next group of decent people who are going to get a ballot paper in their hands are the Germans. The German media are already describing Grillo as the most dangerous man in Europe, as a Fascist, as a populist (what is the matter with populism? [ that is for another post, keep to the point. ed.]) Grillo remarked that the Movement is the French revolution without the guillotine. Angels fear the guillotine is here: that the elites will try to use it - in the end; the independence of the magistrates is already compromised.
Moving down, we have the caretaker government itself. Monti is in Brussels at the moment, reporting in on the control of any livelier responses to internal deflation, and the centralised coverage of lapses in systemically important bank/political administration practices.
The disciplining of regional and local level population, business and contracts is suffering too from the advance of 'irresponsible' voting at local level which has been generated by too much troughing by local administrations, their associated institutions, and their personnel. Attention is to be directed to this problem once our hash has been settled at the centre. However the steady attrition resulting from investigation, charge and arrest of local bankers, institutional administrators various, revelations of hospitals, universities, etc., with big black holes in their institutional fabric - and in the case of schools, roads, entire towns and even cities, their physical fabric too - has been noted as both disruptive of smooth rule and encouraging of our uppity tendencies. There are to be fewer occasions of voting (sinful, voting is) once the response to the outcome of the general election - and here it is arguable that the general election in question is that of 2008 and its presidential subversion - has been settled into place permanently; then the reform of local governance can be decreed once more (the previous decrees fell with the arrival of the national quinquennial requirement to let us out of our boxes).
The media generally are under control, distracted by individual stories of iniquity and exploitation of the public purse, and in any case mostly committed to the bog standard systems of political control currently being finalised at European level. In Italy of course they have especially the mythology of fascism (as well as its realities) to attack in all its 20th century wickedness, leaving its 21st century form, shape-shifting and viciously efficient, free run at our lives, culture and, inter alia, our standard of living and our security (both of which last might reasonably be agreed to be part of the state's remit but not the first two).
Pan-European attempts to portray the Five Stars as clowns, innocents, ignoramuses, have given way to defamation and demonisation. We can expect the first criminalisations shortly, extending beyond the media and into the institutions of our dying democracy. Angels doubt we'll be allowed near a ballot box again any time soon, whatever particular form taken by the 'crisis' justifications being put forward by the Euro-regime (the war on terror now being rather old hat and never awfully popular in Europe).
The next group of decent people who are going to get a ballot paper in their hands are the Germans. The German media are already describing Grillo as the most dangerous man in Europe, as a Fascist, as a populist (what is the matter with populism? [ that is for another post, keep to the point. ed.]) Grillo remarked that the Movement is the French revolution without the guillotine. Angels fear the guillotine is here: that the elites will try to use it - in the end; the independence of the magistrates is already compromised.
Thursday, 14 March 2013
AMDG
A Jesuit robed in white. Who dances the tango. And opens his papacy with the words 'Good evening'. Who reads Hölderlin. And calls himself Francis.
Tuesday, 12 March 2013
The Papacy is not for Encouraging Diversity
Angelo Scola, Archbishop of Milan and sometime Patriarch of Venice, is a philosopher, anthropologist and theologian as well as cardinal of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church. Cardinal Scola comes from that most fortunate of generations when merit could take the son of a lorry driver to fulfilment of his promise and abilities. Note, the fulfilment of promise and abilities: there are many priests at every level yet to achieve their promise, but the papacy is not for those who are still under-qualified. Such office is not for for them because it is not for demonstrating that we are all equal. We aren't. Show who and what you are and then seek our "unconditional reverence and obedience."
How many of us (including some of those who are put forward by themselves and others for the papacy) can even begin to speak like this ?
UPDATE
Black smoke.
Black again
BIANCA [as in fumata, not fumo, ed.]
How many of us (including some of those who are put forward by themselves and others for the papacy) can even begin to speak like this ?
UPDATE
Black smoke.
Black again
BIANCA [as in fumata, not fumo, ed.]
Monday, 11 March 2013
Berlusconi Still in Hospital Despite Legal Efforts to Force Him to Court
The sometime prime minister of Italy Silvio Berlusconi is 76 years old. The recovery of the political position of his political alliance in the last general election to within 0.4 of a percentage point of Pierluigi Bersani's 'winning' alliance 'Common Good' (or 'Common Purpose', as the Italian Bene Comune could readily be translated, and made up of the Democratic Party plus various leftist and Rainbow Alliance splinter groups) was extraordinary. Extraordinary too was Berlusconi's input. Angelo Alfano, the Secretary of the People of Liberty, spoke gracefully and truly when he said that without Berlusconi their defeat would have been far greater than the difficulties Berlsuconi brings along together with his political abilities and near-victory.
Now Angels watches with increasing distaste and democratic concern the legal hounding of Berlusconi. Certainly he has been tried and sentenced in the first instance for tax evasion, and has appealed. But the other crimes of which he is accused fall much closer to the line between criminality and criminalisation. Enticing members of Parliament to cross the floor, even with large cash bungs, is a standard political act; entertaining girls one month from their 18th birthday may be inappropriate for a man of his age but hardly deserving of the montatura of criminal behaviour concocted round his 'tasteful' dinner parties.
There are two horrid aspects to what is going on: an old man hospitalised with health difficulties indicative of much more serious problems, following on his political tour de force, is being examined by judicial order when wholly respectable, indeed distinguished clinicians have certified to the Court that he must stay in hospital: shades of USSR medical and judicial practice; the other horrid aspect is the blind refusal, particularly by sections of the media and so-called intelligentsia, to accept that Silvio Berlusconi is the elected representative of a huge section of the electorate who might reasonably expect their choices to be nurtured at a time of such political tension, rather than the man who carries those choices to be harried by court actions, and even fresh charges that are as tenuously criminal as the older subjects of Berlusconi's trials.
Now Angels watches with increasing distaste and democratic concern the legal hounding of Berlusconi. Certainly he has been tried and sentenced in the first instance for tax evasion, and has appealed. But the other crimes of which he is accused fall much closer to the line between criminality and criminalisation. Enticing members of Parliament to cross the floor, even with large cash bungs, is a standard political act; entertaining girls one month from their 18th birthday may be inappropriate for a man of his age but hardly deserving of the montatura of criminal behaviour concocted round his 'tasteful' dinner parties.
There are two horrid aspects to what is going on: an old man hospitalised with health difficulties indicative of much more serious problems, following on his political tour de force, is being examined by judicial order when wholly respectable, indeed distinguished clinicians have certified to the Court that he must stay in hospital: shades of USSR medical and judicial practice; the other horrid aspect is the blind refusal, particularly by sections of the media and so-called intelligentsia, to accept that Silvio Berlusconi is the elected representative of a huge section of the electorate who might reasonably expect their choices to be nurtured at a time of such political tension, rather than the man who carries those choices to be harried by court actions, and even fresh charges that are as tenuously criminal as the older subjects of Berlusconi's trials.
Friday, 8 March 2013
Berlusconi Admitted to Hospital
Silvio Berlusconi's admission to hospital with uveitis has led to requests to delay the closing arguments of the Ruby trial once more. Folk beliefs about the causes of blindness are being widely and unkindly noted in the Italian media.
Thursday, 7 March 2013
The Defenestration of Siena
The death of David Rossi, the Monte dei Paschi head of communications found on the ground beneath the window of his office at the palazzo Salimbeni yesterday has ended the propaganda push by the Bersani faction of the Democratic Party to involve the Five Stars Movement in any kind of support for a Bersani-led government. That death, however brought about, speaks to the intricacies of the Democratic Party's involvement in the practices at the Bank that have led to a 4 billion euro bail-out by the taxpayer. Five Stars is absolutely justified in wanting nothing to do with the Democratic Party of Italy.
The grip of former members of the Communist Party of Italy on the Democratic Party has been played-down persistently by the media - 'pragmatic', 'former', 'reasonable', 'left of centre' ...on they go pretending that there isn't a problem with this Party. After the ousting of Romano Prodi the problem with the Democratic Party has become the defining problem for the development of any normal left of centre party in Italy. But the European elites will swallow anything provided their project retains support in Member States (and even the in-house journal of the Democratic Party is called Europa). This leads to large-scale misinterpretation of the Five Stars' attitude to forming a government for Italy. The proto-communist Democrats persist in the falsity of pretending to a government coalition with a party whose anti-Europeanism is so marked that the President of the Republic would rather exit office with no elected government formed than call upon Five Stars to form an administration and face the Parliament.
The Democratic central committee and its fellow travellers were both amazed and enraged to find that after their defeat of our attempts to cleanse the Party last November we deserted them in an election they could not fix. They then have tried to smear us as irresponsible and wilfully unco-operative. In everything they say and do they reveal themselves as what they are. Any cover has now been stripped away.
The grip of former members of the Communist Party of Italy on the Democratic Party has been played-down persistently by the media - 'pragmatic', 'former', 'reasonable', 'left of centre' ...on they go pretending that there isn't a problem with this Party. After the ousting of Romano Prodi the problem with the Democratic Party has become the defining problem for the development of any normal left of centre party in Italy. But the European elites will swallow anything provided their project retains support in Member States (and even the in-house journal of the Democratic Party is called Europa). This leads to large-scale misinterpretation of the Five Stars' attitude to forming a government for Italy. The proto-communist Democrats persist in the falsity of pretending to a government coalition with a party whose anti-Europeanism is so marked that the President of the Republic would rather exit office with no elected government formed than call upon Five Stars to form an administration and face the Parliament.
The Democratic central committee and its fellow travellers were both amazed and enraged to find that after their defeat of our attempts to cleanse the Party last November we deserted them in an election they could not fix. They then have tried to smear us as irresponsible and wilfully unco-operative. In everything they say and do they reveal themselves as what they are. Any cover has now been stripped away.
Death in Siena
The body of David Rossi, head of marketing and communications, was found yesterday evening beneath the window of his office at the headquarters of the Monte dei Paschi in the centre of Siena. The window of his office overlooked a little-used, difficult to access side street beside the famous palazzo.
Shortly after half past eight yesterday evening his secretary entered his office and, seeing the open window, looked out to see him lying on the ground some thirty feet below. In the office his computer was turned on, his jacket on his chair. All papers in his office have been sequestered by the investigating magistrate, including a crumpled note, discarded in the wastepaper basket, containing the words "Ho fatto una cavolata" ["I have goofed-up"].
Mr Rossi, a Sienese, had been a close associate of the former President of the Bank, Giuseppe Mussari but was not, himself, under investigation. He had worked with Mussari since the early 1990s and had come with him to the Bank from working with the former mayor of Siena, Pier Luigi Picinni for whom, at that time, Mussari maintained relations between the administration of Siena and the then predominant political party the Democratic Socialists [successors of the recently defunct Communist Party of Italy and now dominant faction in the national Democratic Party led by Bersani.ed.]
Colleagues stated that Rossi was his usual urbane and efficient self in the last days. The Italian media are referring to the death as suicide.
Shortly after half past eight yesterday evening his secretary entered his office and, seeing the open window, looked out to see him lying on the ground some thirty feet below. In the office his computer was turned on, his jacket on his chair. All papers in his office have been sequestered by the investigating magistrate, including a crumpled note, discarded in the wastepaper basket, containing the words "Ho fatto una cavolata" ["I have goofed-up"].
Mr Rossi, a Sienese, had been a close associate of the former President of the Bank, Giuseppe Mussari but was not, himself, under investigation. He had worked with Mussari since the early 1990s and had come with him to the Bank from working with the former mayor of Siena, Pier Luigi Picinni for whom, at that time, Mussari maintained relations between the administration of Siena and the then predominant political party the Democratic Socialists [successors of the recently defunct Communist Party of Italy and now dominant faction in the national Democratic Party led by Bersani.ed.]
Colleagues stated that Rossi was his usual urbane and efficient self in the last days. The Italian media are referring to the death as suicide.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






